3 ms·
That’s like saying that failing to stop your car before you crash means you shouldn’t bother braking at all. Masks have repeatedly been shown to work, indoor di
by acdha 6y ago
That’s like saying that failing to stop your car before you crash means you shouldn’t bother braking at all. Masks have repeatedly been shown to work, indoor dining has repeatedly been shown to be high risk in addition to being an optional luxury, and there’s no world in which we want more spread even if we’d prefer less.
- jdminhbg 6y agoIt’s not like saying that, because nobody has claimed that crashing into another car at 5 mph is the same as crashing into it at 60. When you claim that only “hard lockdowns” (and note the circular reasoning inherent) can have the measurable effects claimed ahead of time, that’s what you’re saying.
- jfrunyon 6y agoNobody has tried to claim that at any point in this thread. You are the only one trying to reduce this to a two-sided issue, which it's not.
- spookthesunset 6y agoAll those things could be true and perhaps banning indoor dining does slow the spread. But is it worth the cost? Why do all these discussions focus only on solving for covid and completely ignoring the costs? If banning indoor dining across the state of California results in one fewer person getting hospitalized is it worth it? What if it keeps 10 people out of the hospital? More generalized, how much benefit does a blanket lockdown have to provide for it to be worth the immense costs. I'm using "cost", by the way, inthe most holistic hippy way possible. Costs include: -- destroyed mental health -- Peoples life work getting shut down by the government -- careers development stalled -- childhood education -- Cancer research getting sidelined -- Preventative healthcare checkups being skipped -- Lost milestones like prom, graduation, awkward teenage dating not happening -- pets not getting routine care because vet appointments are now a pain in the ass -- car oil changes being deferred by 3 months -- adoptions not being performed -- dating lives being put on hold -- people putting off having kids -- infants not seeing human faces can't be good news -- physical health being put on hold (closed gyms) -- and on and on and on. It doesn't take much imagination to see the costs are tremendous. I assert for a lockdown to be worthwhile it has to have such a profound impact on the trajectory of the virus that it is indisputable to the common person. Not only that, but it has to be orders of magnitude better than no lockdown. If somebody is going to argue "see, lockdowns work... this region did 5% better than that region"... I just roll me eyes. It just means we flushed 11 months of people's lives down the toilet for almost no real gain.