3 ms·
In the situation where the argument being put forward relies on the explicitly or implicitly stated expertise of the orator - such as an article which says "Tak
by wittyreference 6y ago
In the situation where the argument being put forward relies on the explicitly or implicitly stated expertise of the orator - such as an article which says "Take heed of my opinion of the important medical factors here, for I am a doctor" - contending that said orator doesn't have that expertise is entirely valid, and not ad hominem. Ad hominem is such when the attack on the orator is orthogonal to their argument.