5 ms·
The simple things that you're describing are all in gmail.
by btilly 15y ago
The simple things that you're describing are all in gmail.
- swaits 15y agoNot really, no.
- btilly 15y agoRead http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=6594 http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=6594 and then tell me which of the simple described features are not in gmail. Be specific so that I can be specific in explaining how it is, in fact, present. (Do remember that gmail's keyboard shortcuts were designed by people who had used Usenet extensively.)
- foobarqux 15y agoHow about "T K" (mark current message and children as read) and "A T" (go up-thread to original post) in gnus. If your claim is that Gmail implements most of the "simple" features present in powerful news-readers then it is manifestly absurd.
- btilly 15y agoMy claim was that the list of things in http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2622662 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2622662 are in gmail. Of course real newsreaders have a lot of features that gmail doesn't.
- yaakov34 15y agoHave to disagree, even though I'm a big gmail user and I do like it way better than the other webmail systems. A thread in gmail looks more like a pile than a real thread - it's nowhere near as smooth as navigating in a newsreader. It presents newer messages on top, and I sometimes find myself confused when I can't tell if certain text is new or quoted in an old message. And there is no "kill thread" - you can set up a filter, but that's a longish operation and I don't think it lets you say "I don't want to follow this particular discussion" as opposed to "filter out this subject/author". It all comes down to gmail being a mail system, not a forum system. And goog's forum system, groups, is pretty sad.
- skybrian 15y agoIn GMail, you can mute a discussion using the "m" key. (There is also a GMail labs feature that makes it work a bit better.) Also, within a thread, new messages are posted at the bottom.
- btilly 15y agoYou should really read through http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=6594 http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=6594 to find out what gmail does that you don't know it does. For instance the "kill thread" functionality that you don't think exists is called mute and is available by pressing m. I stand by my previous comment. Every piece of basic functionality that was requested is actually present in gmail. The aesthetics are not the same, and some things require hitting two keys (for instance y then o to archive the current message and move to the next - keeping the current one from showing up again unless you look for it). But the basic functionality is all there.
- _delirium 15y agoIs there a way to get gmail to highlight posts on mailing lists that are replies to one of your own messages to the list? That's one of the main features of newsreaders I miss (HN's threads?id= view is kind of a clunky approximation).
- btilly 15y agoNot reliably, but here is the best substitute that I am aware of. Click on the icon at the top left, select Email Settings. Search for Personal level indicators and turn them on. Save changes. You'll now have indicators of which emails were sent to you personally, and a stronger indicator of emails sent only to you. When people respond to you they tend to reply to you, so it tends to work out reasonably well.
- _delirium 15y agoThat's pretty useful, thanks! It seems like they ought to be able to directly mark messages which are reply to one of my messages via message-ids, but this does catch the majority of them.