Yeah I really hated this post. Starts off with a flame-baiting title. Then resorts to very qualified statements to support it. After reading it I'm wondering if

Yeah I really hated this post. Starts off with a flame-baiting title. Then resorts to very qualified statements to support it. After reading it I'm wondering if it matters at all and I'm feeling dumb all throughout the discussion. :-( Update: Aarghh, it's just aggravating to read an academic stirring up the pot over some point of theoretical purity. And I love theory too. ;-)