3 ms·
Why does it matter if the flagging is automatic? Does that somehow make it more acceptable? The problem is very simple. Unless social media companies either st
by onion2k 6y ago
Why does it matter if the flagging is automatic? Does that somehow make it more acceptable?
The problem is very simple. Unless social media companies either stop moderating content, which will kill their profits because advertisers will run away, or pay people to moderate everything, which will kill their profit because it'd be wildly expensive, they'll continue to do the half-assed version of moderating they do now using AI and actually make a profit but also make stupid mistakes like this.
Computers and people don't need to operate perfectly. Expecting that is silly. So long as companies deal with errors reasonably it's all good.
- _qulr 6y ago> So long as companies deal with errors reasonably it's all good. We all eagerly await this utopia. Or maybe expecting that is silly, given the many years of empirical evidence?
- qubex 6y agoThere’s plenty of counterexamples one who might wish to dismiss the idea that technology can reasonably manage things, but all things considered, given the number of _potential_ instance of mishap that do not regularly occur any the relatively minor consequences of the mishaps that do occur, I’d conclude that on the whole arguing the original poster’s position is not inherently ‘_silly_’.
- _qulr 6y ago> There’s plenty of counterexamples one who might wish to dismiss the idea that technology can reasonably manage things Are there? How many historical precedents are there for "curation" at the scale of today's tech giants: Facebook, Twitter, Google, Apple App Store, Amazon.com? IMO none of them do it well, or even reasonably. > given the number of _potential_ instance of mishap that do not regularly occur We only hear about the "notable" cases. Every day, people are accidentally or intentionally banned by Twitter or one of the other tech giants, and nobody ever hears about it, because these people are not famous and have nobody else to speak for them and raise a public fuss. > any the relatively minor consequences of the mishaps that do occur Regardless of one's opinion on the matter, you can hardly call the banning of the POTUS, for example, from the world's largest and most important social networks as a "relatively minor consequence". This is very consequential. You may think the consequences are good, or you may think they're bad, but it's consequential. If these "mishaps" are not consequential, why are we all here talking about them?
- sandworm101 6y ago>> stop moderating content, which will kill their profits because advertisers will run away, One common trend for decades has been that "conservative" advertisers quickly acquiesce once they see that their customers do not share such values. Once upon a time major brands wouldn't go anywhere near sexualized content. Now coke/pepsi/ford will pay millions to get their into a Miley Cyrus video. Once upon a time major brands didn't want to be associated with "shock jock" radio hosts. Then Howard Stern made that acceptable and they all jumped on board. Advertisers today don't want to be associated with unmoderated websites. That too will change as such websites become a norm.
- Retric 6y agoSure, 1922 Coke advertising used women in a swimsuit, that’s about as sexualized as a Miley Cyrus video relative to the time period. If anything their very consistent in targeting various segments over time. That said, US social norms get more and less restrictive over time. Dueling for example used to be perfectly legal as was harsh physical punishment for children. What we think of as progress is arguably just increasing similarity with our current views. Continue the same mutability and 2200 might seem much worse to us than today is, but they would similarly think of right now as unbearable.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> 1922 Coke advertising used women in a swimsuit There was far more sexualized content available in the 20s. A girl in a 20s-style 'swimming costume' was the the advertiser acceptable limit at the time for mass media. A Miley Cyrus video would be the sort of content available at 1920s peep shows in bad neighborhoods, content from which advertisers then stay far away. Today they readily endorse it.
- Retric 6y agoThose peep shows where closer to strip joints/late night cable than Miley Cyrus. Full frontal nudity etc. She’s a little past prime time TV, but hardly porn.
- 6y ago
- scbrg 6y ago> Computers and people don't need to operate perfectly. Expecting that is silly. So long as companies deal with errors reasonably it's all good. That depends a lot on the lead time for dealing with the errors, and the magnitude of the negative impact the error has. The lead time for Google dealing with their errors seems to average just below infinity. Twitter, admittedly, is quite a bit better.
- CivBase 6y ago> or pay people to moderate everything, which will kill their profit because it'd be wildly expensive This gets repeated ad nauseam whenever excessive automated moderation is questioned on big platforms, but I have yet to see any actual evidence of it. I don't believe for a second that the likes of Google, Facebook, or Twitter can't afford to turn down their algorithms and significantly increase their manual moderation efforts. Platforms like Reddit and Discord get along alright with limited automated moderation combined with a federated mod structure where most community-specific moderation is handled by unpaid volunteers. Those platforms are gigantic, but they don't make the front page of HN daily for illogical, heavy-handed moderation practices. Besides, nobody expects all moderation to be 100% manual. A lot of content can be reliably identified and moderated by an automated system. Automated systems can even still help with things which they cannot be certain about. Instead of removing the content and taking punitive action against the user, an automated system can just bring the questionable content to the immediate attention of an organization of humans. Not to mention we're talking about some of the wealthiest companies in the world here. Do we have any idea how much they currently spend on manual moderation? Professional content moderation isn't exactly a highly compensated position. I suspect they could increase their moderation workforce by a couple orders of magnitude without the slightest concern about breaking the bank. The big social media platforms complain that significant manual moderation impossibly expensive, but they'll say just about anything to save a dime. That's the real reason they rely so heavily on automated systems - to save as much money as possible. As long as it doesn't cut into their revenue, they'll keep doing it. And if people buy their crap about it being impossible, that suits them just fine.
- LordDragonfang 6y ago>Platforms like Reddit and Discord get along alright with limited automated moderation combined with a federated mod structure Reddit is constantly criticized for the effects of its moderation policies, both in how arbitrary they can seem, and how they allowed genuinely law-breaking content to stay up at the discretion of those "volunteer" moderators. They are practically constantly in the news. (Discord exclusively has invite-only communities, so it's a totally apples-to-oranges comparison) While I would say that reddit's behavior is at least somewhat preferable to the topic of discussion, claiming it's without a similar level of criticism just means you don't actually use the platform. It's also worth pointing out that what others have voiced regarding AI, that such a strategy just serves to deflect blame from the company, is just as true when relying on community volunteers. I suspect that the main reason that they don't make the front page of HN specifically is because "human makes a bad decision" is several orders of magnitude less interesting to this site than "AI makes a bad decision", regardless of the relative social harm.