2 ms·
> You are too discussing ESR here. No, I am not. > You're the one who brought him up in the first place, No, I never mentioned him until you did. > and link
by teddyh 6y ago
> You are too discussing ESR here.
No, I am not.
> You're the one who brought him up in the first place,
No, I never mentioned him until you did.
> and linked to his fund raising page.
No, I did not. I only linked to one page, the page of the SRC project, which is what I wanted to suggest that people might want to evaluate as an alternative to RCS.
> How did I "trap" you into suddenly trying to change the subject? Who did I ask to "cancel" you? That's "physically impossible", as you would say. ;)
[…]
> Is asking you that a "trap" that will "cancel" you if you answer?
Yes. As is obvious to any but the most casual observer.
> > America, conservatives will tell you, is under siege by “cancel culture.” What they won’t tell you is that they couldn’t be happier about it, since it gives them a handy comeback to any criticism, and helps feed their supporters’ sense of victimization.
Which one of us is trying to cancel anyone right now? Me or you? It’s quite obviously you who’s first trying to cancel ESR for some things unrelated to the software which I suggested, and you are then also trying to get me to argue about ESR, which would make me an easy target for suggesting that I would then somehow be on ESR’s side, responsible for ESR’s opinions and thereby making me eligble for cancellation as well.
EDIT:
> You're on record as having submitted two of his other ridiculously arrogant articles to Hacker News […] you're obviously a fan of his. […] Were you seriously suggesting that ESR would be a good person to collaborate with on developing a source code control system, despite all the evidence? Please explain why. Do you still endorse contributing to his fundraising campaign that you linked to?
Apparently having submitted articles by ESR three years ago is enough to get me smeared as supporting whatever ESR is being accused of. I’m feeling seriously stalked here.
(You neglect to mention that I have also submitted to HN your story about Sun Microsystems PizzaTool. Does this mean that I also endorse your opinions?)
- DonHopkins 6y agoTrying to engage you in a conversation is not canceling you, buddy. If you admit it's obvious to the most casual observer that your answer will trap you, then it also must be obvious what your answer would be, so why not admit that too? If you don't want people to discuss ESR, then you're the one who is canceling instead of defending him. More than half the word count on the page you linked to was dedicated to fundraising, so yes, it was a fundraising page. In response to my evidence, you confidently claimed "I’m sure all your claims can be either explained as inconsequential or disproven as false", but you failed to refute what I said, and refused to discuss it further. Do you also accuse me of lying about the fact that you've submitted two other links to his pretentious "Hacker" articles to Hacker News in the past? It sure sounds like you're afraid of being associated with ESR, and desperate to change the subject that you brought up, to the most casual observer.
- teddyh 6y ago> More than half the word count on the page you linked to was dedicated to fundraising, so yes, it was a fundraising page. Regardless of the contents of the web page, it is the official home page for the project; what else was I going to link to? I also disagree about your characterization of the page; I invite anyone to read the page themselves to see if they agree with your description. > you failed to refute what I said, and refused to discuss it further. Yes. Because this is not the time or place for it. This is supposed to be about SCCS. Even if it were somehow appropriate, I have more sense than to try and defeat your Gish gallop. And even though I didn’t bite, you were quick to move on to attacking me: > It sure sounds like you're afraid of being associated with ESR, and desperate to change the subject that you brought up, to the most casual observer. It sure sounds like you’re desperate to both attack ESR at any opportunity and also to smear any opposition as “fans” of ESR who must obviously support his views. At this stage, I am more worried about being associated with you. I did submit an article of yours too, you know.
- DonHopkins 6y agoYou certainly could have linked to the actual official gitlab page of the project itself, instead of ESR's unofficial fundraising page on his own personal web site. You're the one who dragged ESR into it, when you should have pointed directly to the official project, not one person's fundraising page. And yes, there actually are more words on that unofficial personal page you linked to about fundraising than about SCR itself, so what I said is not a mischaracterization. Go count them. I get 186 fundraising : 104 SCR, or 65% fundraising (not counting punctuation as white space, so a url counts as one word -- maybe I'm off by one or two, but it was a free and fair election). What do you count? The official gitlab page you should have linked to doesn't have any fundraising appeals or links at all (0% fundraising, 100% SCR), but it does have the most recent version. Why would you point to an out-of-date snapshot of the project, instead of the live latest version? It was originally a Gish Gallop when ESR said those words in the first place, because he says such things again and again, but it's only a Gish Gallop if it's not true. But ESR's own words I quoted are all actual things he really said, as unbelievable as it may be to you. You baselessly accused me of lying about it, then repeatedly refused to prove I'm wrong, after confidently claiming without evidence that "I’m sure all your claims can be either explained as inconsequential or disproven as false". There are a hell of a lot more vile ESR quotes that support my point, so many in fact that people have donated $100,000 to make Thomas Ptacek stop posting them, and you should be grateful I only posted a few. Literally quoting somebody's own words is not a "Gish Gallop", nor "canceling" them. You're biting again and again, yet still failing to answer the simple questions that you're afraid will "trap" you into admitting something you obviously don't want to say. Do you still accuse me of lying about those ESR quotes and word counts, or not? Then prove it, or apologize for falsely calling me a liar.