3 ms·
Man, that is almost a textbook example of an ad hominem attack. I try to recommend some useful software, and you go on an unrelated rant about its author, in a
by teddyh 6y ago
Man, that is almost a textbook example of an ad hominem attack.
I try to recommend some useful software, and you go on an unrelated rant about its author, in an obvious attempt to have him cancelled and all his works expunged.
I’m sure all your claims can be either explained as inconsequential or disproven as false, but this is not the time and place for it. Take your ESR-bashing somewhere else.
- DonHopkins 6y agoI want people to know about him, and what he's said. And so does he, even more than I do! So I'm doing him a favor, literally spreading his own words, and giving him a platform, not canceling him. You linked to his appeal for financial support. So did you already know all about him when you recommended his software, or were those quotes and his reputation for misogyny and racism news to you? You seem pretty Dunning-Kruger sure of yourself that all of my claims and evidence I linked to about ESR are "either explained as inconsequential or disproven as false", but you're wrong, so of course you don't want to discuss the person whose project and appeal for financial donations you linked to and endorsed.
- teddyh 6y ago> So did you already know about him when you recommended his software, or were those quotes news to you? I’m not discussing ESR here. I’m discussing you, and your transparent attempt to trap me and try and have me cancelled as well.
- DonHopkins 6y agoWhat are you even talking about? You are too discussing ESR here. You're the one who brought him up in the first place, and linked to his SRC fund raising page. How did I "trap" you into suddenly trying to change the subject? Who did I ask to "cancel" you? That's "physically impossible", as you would say. ;) Again: did you already know about ESR's racism and misogyny and narcissism, or not? Were those quotes news to you? Do you still dispute them? Is asking you those questions a "trap" that will "cancel" you if you answer, so now you want to change the subject? You're on record as having submitted two of his other ridiculously arrogant articles to Hacker News: "How to Become a Hacker" (3 points by teddyh on March 24, 2016), and "Things Every Hacker Once Knew" (7 points by teddyh on Jan 26, 2017), although there were few points and no comments on either. That proves you've read his articles and known of him for at least five years, and you're obviously a fan of his. So let's hear your side of the story, instead of changing the subject or canceling you, please. Were you seriously suggesting that ESR would be a good person to collaborate with on developing a source code control system, despite all the evidence? Please explain why. Do you still endorse contributing to his fundraising campaign that you linked to? Have you put your money where your mouth is by contributing to it yourself? I believe Thomas Ptacek's self-cancelation fundraising campaign is over, but it was a great idea, so how much will you pay me to cancel myself, stop quoting ESR, and change the subject? Funny how most of the people whining about cancel culture actually want to cancel other people themselves, while playing the victim, because they have reprehensible believes they can't defend, and don't want to face the consequences of their own words and deeds. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/02/19/nobody-loves-cancel-culture-more-than-republicans-do/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/02/19/nobody-lo... >Opinion: Nobody loves ‘cancel culture’ more than Republicans do >America, conservatives will tell you, is under siege by “cancel culture.” What they won’t tell you is that they couldn’t be happier about it, since it gives them a handy comeback to any criticism, and helps feed their supporters’ sense of victimization. >Consider the defense Donald Trump Jr. offered of Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz’s jaunt to Cancun while millions of his Texas constituents froze without power. >“The optics of that right now isn’t ideal,” Trump Jr. admitted in a video posted to social media, but “I’m not going to jump on this bandwagon of trying to cancel the guy.” Because Cruz is the real victim here.
- teddyh 6y ago> You are too discussing ESR here. No, I am not. > You're the one who brought him up in the first place, No, I never mentioned him until you did. > and linked to his fund raising page. No, I did not. I only linked to one page, the page of the SRC project, which is what I wanted to suggest that people might want to evaluate as an alternative to RCS. > How did I "trap" you into suddenly trying to change the subject? Who did I ask to "cancel" you? That's "physically impossible", as you would say. ;) […] > Is asking you that a "trap" that will "cancel" you if you answer? Yes. As is obvious to any but the most casual observer. > > America, conservatives will tell you, is under siege by “cancel culture.” What they won’t tell you is that they couldn’t be happier about it, since it gives them a handy comeback to any criticism, and helps feed their supporters’ sense of victimization. Which one of us is trying to cancel anyone right now? Me or you? It’s quite obviously you who’s first trying to cancel ESR for some things unrelated to the software which I suggested, and you are then also trying to get me to argue about ESR, which would make me an easy target for suggesting that I would then somehow be on ESR’s side, responsible for ESR’s opinions and thereby making me eligble for cancellation as well. EDIT: > You're on record as having submitted two of his other ridiculously arrogant articles to Hacker News […] you're obviously a fan of his. […] Were you seriously suggesting that ESR would be a good person to collaborate with on developing a source code control system, despite all the evidence? Please explain why. Do you still endorse contributing to his fundraising campaign that you linked to? Apparently having submitted articles by ESR three years ago is enough to get me smeared as supporting whatever ESR is being accused of. I’m feeling seriously stalked here. (You neglect to mention that I have also submitted to HN your story about Sun Microsystems PizzaTool. Does this mean that I also endorse your opinions?)
- DonHopkins 6y agoTrying to engage you in a conversation is not canceling you, buddy. If you admit it's obvious to the most casual observer that your answer will trap you, then it also must be obvious what your answer would be, so why not admit that too? If you don't want people to discuss ESR, then you're the one who is canceling instead of defending him. More than half the word count on the page you linked to was dedicated to fundraising, so yes, it was a fundraising page. In response to my evidence, you confidently claimed "I’m sure all your claims can be either explained as inconsequential or disproven as false", but you failed to refute what I said, and refused to discuss it further. Do you also accuse me of lying about the fact that you've submitted two other links to his pretentious "Hacker" articles to Hacker News in the past? It sure sounds like you're afraid of being associated with ESR, and desperate to change the subject that you brought up, to the most casual observer.
- cmiles74 6y agoReminding the rest of us who ESR actually is strikes me as helpful, the link is to one of his projects. In terms of "cancelling" him, isn't that up to individuals who decide they do not want to use his software?