3 ms·
"It’s extremely unusual for a paper to be delayed this long, and then to appear simultaneously with its critiques. Usually the paper is published and then the
by tokenadult 15y ago
"It’s extremely unusual for a paper to be delayed this long, and then to appear simultaneously with its critiques. Usually the paper is published and then the critiques (with a response by the authors of the original paper) appear in the journal a few months later."
Indeed. The paper claiming to find a life form on earth with arsenic incorporated in its DNA molecules made an extraordinary claim, and received extraordinary treatment from the press. But it hasn't been backed up by the extraordinary evidence necessary for believing an extraordinary claim.