5 ms·
> However, the idea that we should design our energy policy around maximizing new energy creation even when it's more cost effective to make our current product
by anamax 18y ago
> However, the idea that we should design our energy policy around maximizing new energy creation even when it's more cost effective to make our current products more energy efficient makes no sense, assuming we take economic benefit to mean wealth created per dollar spent.
Sure it does. Even if we made all of our current products us 0 energy, we might want more energy for other things than the amount saved.
BTW - is it actually more cost-efficient or is that assumed because it's convenient for some other argument?
- pchristensen 18y agoIn the sense that pure markets are the most effective known way to efficiently allocate resources. In reality they can fall short in any number of ways. Cap-and-trade for sulfur dioxide is the poster child. It has worked well in reducing overall levels quickly and cost effectively: http://www.grinningplanet.com/2004/02-12/cap-and-trade-pollution-credits-eco.htm http://www.grinningplanet.com/2004/02-12/cap-and-trade-pollu... . But I don't know of any other examples of cap-and-trade so it's not clear it's an all-purpose strategy.
- Alex3917 18y agoIt works as long as you have an accurate historical baseline and you are able to accurately track the amount emitted by each source. IIRC cap-and-trade has been used successfully in a few other places, but I don't know where offhand. On the other hand, I do know that a tax has never solved a single air pollution problem anywhere in the world.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Even if we made all of our current products us 0 energy, we might want more energy for other things than the amount saved." Let's say it costs 5 dollars to save one kilowatt of electricity. Let's also say it costs 20 dollars to generate one new kilowatt of electricity. Both ways, we get one new kilowatt of electricity, but one way is less expensive. Of course at any given time we would be pursuing a mix of strategies that involve both new generation and conservation. We should always pursue the mix of strategies that is the least expensive, assuming the cost of carbon is internalized.
- anamax 18y ago> Let's say it costs 5 dollars to save one kilowatt of electricity. Let's also say it costs 20 dollars to generate one new kilowatt of electricity. Both ways, we get one new kilowatt of electricity, but one way is less expensive. Except that energy saving is capped. If we're using 5kw and we want 100kw, saving that 5 is nice but only 5% of the goal. And yes, we're going to need significantly energy than we have today. The first of those "extra uses" are also known as India and China. Also, while the assumption that energy savings costs 25% of new production costs is convenient for an argument, it isn't all that common. People don't spend more money than they have to. As energy costs have gone up, the low-hanging fruit has been picked. Of course, some folks cheat by including "savings" that requires changing behavior/reducing value and assuming that that's cost free. That's wrong because minimum energy use isn't the goal - the goal is to maximize value for cost. Just because you don't see the value of something that uses energy doesn't mean that everyone else agrees.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Except that energy saving is capped. If we're using 5kw and we want 100kw, saving that 5 is nice but only 5% of the goal." Your argument is flawed because you are assuming that you either have to create new electricity or conserve electricity and you can't do both. The least expensive way to get X units of new energy is always going to be some mix of conservation and creation, and the free market lets us find the most efficient point along the spectrum. "People don't spend more money than they have to. As energy costs have gone up, the low-hanging fruit has been picked." http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2008/07/28/energy_efficiency/?source=newsletter http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2008/07/28/energy_efficien...
- anamax 18y ago>> "Except that energy saving is capped. If we're using 5kw and we want 100kw, saving that 5 is nice but only 5% of the goal." >Your argument is flawed because you are assuming that you either have to create new electricity or conserve electricity and you can't do both. Huh? In my example, I did both. I should have written that the low-hanging fruit is being picked. The fact remains that expected energy demand exceeds current capacity. That means that savings can't get us out of the problem. Also, if you care about CO2, you want to replace existing sources even if the existing sources provide enough energy.