3 ms·
I like this site, but honestly the most annoying thing is that there isn't a way to opt-out of the karma system visibly. Why can't there be a check box that sto
by endisneigh 6y ago
I like this site, but honestly the most annoying thing is that there isn't a way to opt-out of the karma system visibly. Why can't there be a check box that stops showing me my karma and greying out downvoted posts? There's no way it would take more than an hour to implement this.
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoSeems like a user style sheet would fix this.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoDang actually considers the comment fading an absolutely essential feature: > The fading is an important element of HN's design—I don't mean its web design, I mean its community design. It's one critical way in which the community signals that it has found something wrong with a comment. > These signals are extremely important for calibrating users' perceptions of the community—especially new users. > I think it was one of pg's master strokes actually. For all its annoyance, it creates important feedback loops, both within the community and between the community and the outside world. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24334263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24334263
- endisneigh 6y agothe same could be said about flagged comments but you can opt out of the default behavior there. there's basically no excuse imo. if this site was open source a I'd create a pull request, but alas.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYou can opt into seeing dead comments, but they're still clearly delineated as dead, alongside maximum fading.
- endisneigh 6y agoyes, exactly - if what I described existed you could still see your karma by clicking your profile and downvoted comments could still be marked as such by simply saying so instead of ruining accessibility and graying it out, making it harder to read. the ability to click the comment and see it no longer grayed out isn't really a solution since it's still harder to read the comment and ascertain whether it would be worth clicking it to begin with.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe first personal browser extensión I ever wrote was to let me hover greyed out HN posts to read them. Dang’s justification is no reason to make them illegible. There’s just as much reason then to let people read it and see what behavior is looked down on here.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThe fading disappears if you click "X minutes ago" above the comment, so they're always readable. (Your extension sounds like a nice solution too, though.)
- pirocks 6y agoPerhaps it's just your display/eyes? I find them readable even on maximum fade.
- unabst 6y agoI get it, but this position makes HN definitively anti-free speech. You restrict speech and you restrict how people think. Calibrating speech is not free speech and neither is fading speech. > the community signals that it has found something wrong with a comment. A bully fat shaming would be "the community signaling that there is something wrong". The HN equivalent would be PC shaming. What someone thinks of something has no bearing on right or wrong. Also "the community" isn't downvoting. It's always an individual. A sincere course correcting response is the simple and natural fix, and what already happens. Downvoting helps with reducing responses, but comments are people. People do not enjoy being reduced. > extremely important for calibrating users' perceptions of the community I have enough experience now that I can write in HN mode. I cannot however, think in HN mode. I try, but whenever I think, comments like this one happens. This comment also violates the "ideology battle" clause from the HN guidelines because I am not allowed to fight for free speech. But stories about politics and ideologies make the top page all the time, and aren't most good disagreements ideological? Tabs versus spaces, React versus Vue, Open versus Closed source. Downvoting. The technical part is never that deep. The deepest it can get is deeply technical. With all that said, everything else about HN is the best on the internet hands down.
- pjc50 6y ago> I get it, but this position makes HN definitively anti-free speech This is absolutely necessary to have a community. The moderation, both centralised in dang and distributed among the downvoters, is what makes HN HN and not a chan board. Removing comments deemed "bad" and thereby discouraging people from posting them in the first place adds value to the site. It is far from perfect, but it's better than nothing. > People do not enjoy being reduced. No, but people don't enjoy being insulted either, and nor do they enjoy the "oh not this again" feeling that makes them reach for the downvote button in the first place. (Disclaimer: I'm #24 in HN karma and #32 on electronics.stackexchange, so undoubtedly count as deeply embedded with the ""establishment"" downvoting all the edgy rebels)
- unabst 6y agoIf it's far from perfect, let's improve it. It's not downvote or nothing. Downvotes are meant to tame the insults and offensive comments. But what if downvotes themselves are insulting and offensive? Are there really no other options? But the even deeper issue is that this may be the HN the moderators want, and it does sound like it is. Deeper issues are often ideological discussions. Yet, ideological battles are not to be fought on HN. But the ideology needs to be settled before technical solutions can commence. Implementing a better downvote or an alternative is a technical problem. Deciding to do so requires ideological decisions, such as, prioritize free speech.
- alacombe 6y ago> Dang actually considers the comment fading an absolutely essential feature: All rulers like the tools helping them reign over their fiefdom. edit: I actually do most of my HN reading through premii.com, so I ignore all the fading and all the stupid pagination.
- bdibs 6y agoI thought that sounded like a fun project to learn web extensions and decided to make a Chrome extension for that today: https://github.com/bdibs/DeKarmaHN https://github.com/bdibs/DeKarmaHN. Hope it works for you.