3 ms·
> Why couldn't you give it your phone's IP? Because my phone frequently changes IP as I connect to different networks. It's dynamic, not static. > You could j
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> Why couldn't you give it your phone's IP?
Because my phone frequently changes IP as I connect to different networks. It's dynamic, not static.
> You could just as easily use USB, Bluetooth, or local wifi, none of which require anything other than your phone and your car.
USB is wired.
Bluetooth requires me to by physical standing by my car.
My car and phone may not be on the same WiFi.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoWell, yes, if you refuse to connect your phone to your car then you will need an intermediary to connect your phone to your car. The vast majority of people would be fine with a setup that syncs their phone and car when they're in the car, though; I assume I'm not that rare in that I always plug in my phone when I get in the car in order to use it with the dashboard anyways (Apple CarPlay / Android Auto), at which point it might as well sync any info I want.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI can't understand you. If you want to remotely start your car to warm it up from a mile away, then by definition you're not going to be sitting in your car connected with a physical wire, are you? And whatever your IP was the last time you plugged in may have changed by now. Do phone networks even let you accept incoming connections from non-approved services? Does not compute. > The vast majority of people would be fine with a setup that syncs their phone and car when they're in the car, though I think demand for wireless car functionality in practice in the market (it's often an optional extra - people pay real money for it) shows you you're wrong.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> If you want to remotely start your car to warm it up from a mile away, then by definition you're not going to be sitting in your car connected with a physical wire, are you? Oh, yes, in that case we're totally talking past each other and you have a completely valid point. I was originally responding to: > journey logging, fuel status, access from an app which should be perfectly doable locally, but agreed that [very] remote start is likely to need some sort of intermediary. > I think demand for wireless car functionality in practice in the market (it's often an optional extra - people pay real money for it) shows you you're wrong. Possible; it certainly wouldn't be the first time that I had very different preferences from 99% of the population without noticing...
- throwawayboise 6y ago> people pay real money for it I'm not sure that's clear. Almost nobody custom orders options on cars anymore. They take what's in stock or readily available at the dealer, and those are mostly the fully-loaded models. Yes, they are buying it and paying for it, but do they really have a choice?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Almost nobody custom orders options on cars anymore. They take what's in stock or readily available at the dealer I think this is a uniquely American thing. In Europe, Asia, etc, most people custom order a configuration on a website that’s then built at the factory and delivered to the dealer where they pick it up.