3 ms·
> Remote unlock is the least of the problems here, the real issue is that cars have no business being connected to the vendors servers at all. Why do you think
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> Remote unlock is the least of the problems here, the real issue is that cars have no business being connected to the vendors servers at all.
Why do you think that? It provides valuable functionality that I use, such as journey logging, fuel status, access from an app, and so on. You need an intermediate server run by the vendor. I can't give it my phone's IP address, can I!
- cwalv 6y agoMaybe something simpler like a stun/turn server would be enough. Or something with no infrastructure (or recurring fees) at all, only working in my local network (like my printer).
- chrisseaton 6y agoI can understand that's attractive to a techie, but approximately nobody else wants to manage that kind of setup.
- avianlyric 6y agoWhat is there to manage? Plenty of devices work just fine on local networks without the need of a mothership to act as a bridge. Just look at almost any Apple P2P service, such as AirDrop, Wifi Password sharing, Handoff, AirPlay etc Zero management need by the customer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm not sure you understand the use-case here - Apple P2P services are about working on a local network. But that doesn't apply here, does it? My car and my phone obviously aren't on a local network, are they? How do you propose to establish a local network remotely? Some kind of VPN? You'd need to establish a connection via some kind of centralised server... run by a vendor.
- avianlyric 6y agoAs the previous poster mentioned, that can be achieved with much simpler STUN/TURN servers provided by the vendor, that don’t take active part in sending commands etc, they just provide a basic pipe to route traffic through. Frequently they can even provide that pipe by just providing some help to link two devices so they can do direct P2P. In this environment the vendors doesn’t get to watch and inspect the content of what’s transmitted, their devices don’t phone home, and the service is trivial to restore because they’re pretty much stateless.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoSounds like you've accepted the vendors do really need to run a service, and it can't be local, and now you're just debating how big that service needs to be.
- theamk 6y agoThere is a mothership -- it is just built into an Apple device, and Apple spent a lot of effort getting this all to work, and they can only get it to work because they control all sides. Try setting up a generic wlan-compatible printer and a macOS laptop on a local network. I have such setup, and it is just fails every once in a while for no reason. I would not recommend this to anyone over well-run centralized server.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> You need an intermediate server run by the vendor. I can't give it my phone's IP address, can I! 1. Why couldn't you give it your phone's IP? 2. You could just as easily use USB, Bluetooth, or local wifi, none of which require anything other than your phone and your car.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Why couldn't you give it your phone's IP? Because my phone frequently changes IP as I connect to different networks. It's dynamic, not static. > You could just as easily use USB, Bluetooth, or local wifi, none of which require anything other than your phone and your car. USB is wired. Bluetooth requires me to by physical standing by my car. My car and phone may not be on the same WiFi.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoWell, yes, if you refuse to connect your phone to your car then you will need an intermediary to connect your phone to your car. The vast majority of people would be fine with a setup that syncs their phone and car when they're in the car, though; I assume I'm not that rare in that I always plug in my phone when I get in the car in order to use it with the dashboard anyways (Apple CarPlay / Android Auto), at which point it might as well sync any info I want.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI can't understand you. If you want to remotely start your car to warm it up from a mile away, then by definition you're not going to be sitting in your car connected with a physical wire, are you? And whatever your IP was the last time you plugged in may have changed by now. Do phone networks even let you accept incoming connections from non-approved services? Does not compute. > The vast majority of people would be fine with a setup that syncs their phone and car when they're in the car, though I think demand for wireless car functionality in practice in the market (it's often an optional extra - people pay real money for it) shows you you're wrong.