3 ms·
I think quite the opposite: the vast difference between living beings' ability to learm how to exist in their environment (including other living beings and som
by tsimionescu 6y ago
I think quite the opposite: the vast difference between living beings' ability to learm how to exist in their environment (including other living beings and sometimes social structures) and the very limited successes of even modern AI still show that we are very far away from AGI.
We couldn't create an ant AI right now, imagining we are pretty close to a human is pretty absurd.
And if we're taking about intelligence, human exceptionalism is hard to argue against (in the context of Earth, no point in speculating about alien life). There are pretty few creatures on earth trying to build AIs, and I for one would not consider something to be an AGI if it couldn't even understand the concept.
- LesZedCB 6y ago> We couldn't create an ant AI right now, imagining we are pretty close to a human is pretty absurd i dont care about "human level intelligence," just a general unsupervised learning agent that can interact with the world (i recognize the insufficiency of this definition. i'm not writing an essay here) will suffice for me. human level is just another iteration(s) after that.
- tsimionescu 6y agoAgreed, but my claim is exactly that we are obviously far from that. In fact, all current training methods work only on very precisely defined problems. Both the relevant inputs and desired outputs must be very precisely defined, and come in rather small numbers, for any success with current methods. Trying to use the existing methods on a problem as open as living in the world would require so much computing power, and so many petabytes of training data (not that we would know how to generate this training data, a hard problem in itself, regardless of scale), that hardly anyone is even attempting it.
- LesZedCB 6y agoyeah i think we are in agreement about current methods. i guess my real hypothesis is that there are more people than ever looking at AI. we don't have the right algorithm or framework yet, and currently models probably wont iterate to it. but a hard takeoff when we do find it is practically inevitable, in my opinion. i think AI experts are limited to thinking in terms of the field as it is, or where it will be in less than five years, not what will happen when somebody stumbles on the right model.