6 ms·
I mean how else would ransomware authors demand payment? Classical solutions are too easy to trace. This is one of the worst byproducts of crypto. Turns out per
by arcticbull 6y ago
I mean how else would ransomware authors demand payment? Classical solutions are too easy to trace. This is one of the worst byproducts of crypto. Turns out permissionless means people you don’t want using the system, using the system for things you don’t want them doing. Who’d have thought.
- sn_master 6y agoMonero. Its designed to be far less tracable than BTC and many exchanges exist online that trade XMR for BTC. I am surprised BTC still has this large presence in the blackmarket.
- arcticbull 6y agoXMR has too little plausible deniability at the onramp and offramp, and is getting delisted from exchanges. Like any money laundering business the process relies on plausible deniability. Think Los Pollos Hermanos. Monero markets itself to criminals. Bitcoin to speculators and ancaps. You can hide your BTC gains by saying you made some leveraged trades in Malta. You can’t hide your Monero gains. Ironically it’s what makes it better at its job that makes it less useful. You really want to toe the line.
- kache_ 6y agoBlockchain analysis makes it extremely difficult to hide bitcoin. Not only that, but bitcoin in general can be blacklisted/tainted.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoHonest question: does that mean anything on a DEX?
- wmf 6y agoIdeally everything coming out of DEXes (and offshore exchanges) should be marked as dirty but that doesn't seem to be happening.
- smabie 6y agopretty easy to launder BTC actually using tornado
- vmception 6y agoYou feel that way, but its not a complete reality. For more than half a decade many bitcoin invoices have actually been paid with Monero and we don't have a way to quantify that except to participate in forums where people talk about what they do. The merchants wouldn't even know if thats what happened. For every XMR.to that shuts down, another has already risen and is just waiting for marketshare. There are also trusted bridges between blockchains. And people are still working on trustless bridges compatible with Monero, which will really unlock its value and make exchanges completely ignorable. Ultimately the state will never accomplish its goal of strongarming the intermediary.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Ultimately the state will never accomplish its goal of strongarming the intermediary. Wow it’s like reading 1984. The uh, first part of course, not the end. If you haven’t read it I don’t want to ruin the surprise.
- vmception 6y agoA non-sequitur. Monero is compliant with all FATF goals. The state has gotten used to surveillance of digital transactions over the past 50 years by deputizing financial institutions, this was a temporary convenience for them and now digital transactions don't require financial institutions, which is simply a reversion to a mean with a millenium of precedent. For now they can strongarm the intermediary as they havent even noticed that they’ve just been taking a convenience for granted, but the reality is pretty clear: the state will have to deter whichever activities they dont like by actually investigating and stopping that person as regulating/strongarming the intermediary wont be a tool they have anymore.
- arcticbull 6y agoTrust me the boundary between the shadow market and the real economy (where such systems would be illegal) is where the friction will always be and remain. Trade away, have fun, as soon as you try and convert to real money they’ll come down on you like the sword of Damocles fell. The only reason this isn’t more frictional is because the government has bigger things to worry about. They simply don’t care about you. The second that changes you’ll be trading in the digital equivalent of suitcases full of prepaid gift cards. This isn’t a new game lol, it’s been played to death and one side has a lot more experience than the other.
- capeterson 6y ago> I am surprised BTC still has this large presence in the blackmarket. The people buying goods online are not usually very tech savvy, so you lose a lot of potential customers by requiring a difficult-to-acquire cryptocurrency. Those selling the goods usually know what's up though, so they're still going to be doing the BTC->XMR->BTC->exchange swap in order to hide their identity. edit: You would be surprised how dumb some people are online though. Nowadays folks are a bit wiser, but the original silk road got taken down because they used hotmail, lol.
- Namidairo 6y ago> so they're still going to be doing the BTC->XMR->BTC->exchange swap in order to hide their identity. Wouldn't this just shift the risk to the exchanges who are now holding tracable proceeds of crime? To my knowledge, there is at least some amount of identity verification on the major exchanges, so presumably that they're fronting with stolen identity documents and the exchange is the one "holding the bag" so to speak?
- capeterson 6y agoMmm it's not too hard to get use a decentralized exchange to get cash overnighted for BTC sent to a PO box that was made with a fake name and cash. You can't really spend/deposit that cash easily, but at least it's not crypto anymore. Also, it's pretty much impossible to fraud Coinbase/Gemini/etc. since you need to hook it up to your bank account, right. Ergo, no one is sending BTC (even if it's "clean") to an exchange hooked up to their bank account. If someone is thorough it's highly unlikely that clean BTC will get them imprisoned, but the IRS might take a hefty cut that vendors of course would prefer to circumvent. Many vendors also don't cash out until they're completely clean, if they can afford to.
- 8note 6y agoI'd imagine this is the primary usecase of bitcoin? Existing transactions cover other usecases just fine
- user-the-name 6y agoCryptocurrency is basically the one thing that has allowed ransomware to thrive.
- fasdf1122 6y agolol, miss the boat?
- Grim-444 6y agoI guess I don't really understand what the plan is, since all bitcoin transactions have a permanent record that are publicly viewable by all. You can't hide bitcoin, every transaction they were involved in is recorded. If they ever want to turn the bitcoin back into real currency they need to go through an exchange to convert it, and the gov can just ask the exchange for the info / bank account of the person associated with the bitcoin.
- user-the-name 6y agoYou can tumble bitcoins. You can use decentralised and/or dodgy exchanges to change bitcoin into other cryptocurrencies, and then back after breaking the trail.
- rdsubhas 6y agoAnswer: No jurisdictive boundary. When you transfer to a bank account, it cannot move out of the country's jurisdiction without triggering multiple regulatory touchpoints. It's not easy to cash the money out overseas. But when you transfer bitcoin, it's done once to a virtual ID. The person receiving doesn't need any online account. You can't trace anything here. It's just "sending from wallet id X to wallet id Y". wallet id Y is just a cryptographic key known to the sender and receiver. Yeah so this "virtual ID" is replicated across the network, but who cares. It doesn't point to anyone yet. After this single step, there is no jurisdiction. The hacker can travel and cash it anywhere in the world outside jurisdiction of the host country's law enforcement.
- graeme 6y agoBut in the case of a financial crime targeting us interests the Us claims pretty much universal jurisdiction and they assert strong influence over global banking. So how do the coins evade that since any transfer is traceable on the blockchain?
- bradleyjg 6y agoI’m as anti-Bitcoin as the next guy, but I still don’t see how it enables all these ransomware attacks. If the federal government were serious about pursuing this why not just follow the public, immutable transfer record and indict and sanction everyone associated with any entity along the way? Not being able to do business with any business that does business in the United States is a pretty big deal. Not to mention your executives not being able to travel anywhere with an extradition treaty.
- runeks 6y agoIt will probably end up this way. “All outputs in the Bitcoin transaction with hash <...> are illegal to redeem.” This, however, means that criminals (who don’t care about the law) can still use these segregated Bitcoin to transact between themselves — as long as miners aren’t punished by including the illegal transactions in new blocks.
- bradleyjg 6y agoThat seems like the bare minimum but I expect that at some point a ransomware will hit a high enough profile target that the federal goes through the effort of actually tracking down recipients.