4 ms·
We should use the term "censorship", not "moderation", where one party prevents another from saying something. Calling it "moderation" is an attempt to sugar-co
by Animats 6y ago
We should use the term "censorship", not "moderation", where one party prevents another from saying something. Calling it "moderation" is an attempt to sugar-coat censorship.
Arguably, if a private company is pressured to censor by a government, their censorship actions becomes state action. First Amendment protections may apply in the US. This is an unresolved area in US law. It's come up where cities have outsourced management of some public spaces such as parks and plazas, and the outsourcing company prohibited protests.[1]
Worth seeing: "Censored", an official U.S. Government training cartoon from WWII. Written by "Dr. Seuss", by the way.[2] In that era, censorship was made very explicit. Letters didn't just disappear. They had sections cut out and were stamped "Opened by Censor".
Maybe if you put your name on it, you should be able to say it without prior restraint. Most of the serious problems come from anonymous speech.
[1] https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-detroit-agree-interim-rules-protect-free-speech-public-parks https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-detroit-agree-inter...
[2] https://catalog.archives.gov/id/35864 https://catalog.archives.gov/id/35864
- dan-robertson 6y agoQuestion for you: do you have an example of something that most people on this message board might class as moderation, but which you wouldn’t call censorship?
- dan-robertson 6y agoI guess I’m just ok with censorship in a lot of situations. Perhaps if online discussion and therefore (by your standard) censorship were more decentralised then it would be more fair but it seems people don’t want something decentralised.