4 ms·
Why the US sucks at building public transit
- viburnum 6y agoEven if you got the construction costs down and were willing to suffer the inefficiency of low population densities, neighborhood streets and buildings are still hostile to people who aren’t in cars. To do it right you have to rethink every inch space, curbs, power lines, street width, driveways, lot sizes, load zones, commercial zoning, etc. For example, new urban buildings in American cities typically have underground parking. So a store or a restaurant in an old building that was 100 feet deep would have had a back area for storage or kitchens. In new construction at street level there are ramps down to the garage, so the commercial spaces are much shallower. That’s why the old shops and restaurants are typically replaced by Subway, tanning salons, and banks. Now the neighborhood services and amenities are harder to get to, which creates more work for the transit system. There are good solutions to these problems but it requires looking at the big picture.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThis Bay Area project summarizes how bad the US sucks at public transit now: "VTA broke ground on the $2.3 billion, 10-mile, two-station extension in April 2012." Including planning, that's more than 10 years to add 2 above-ground stations and track on existing right-of-ways that goes 10 miles, for $2.3 billion. This is not high-speed rail - it goes at walking speed. The only good thing I can say is that at least it's done, but SJC's new airport terminal was only $1.3 billion by comparison. (That project had a professional out-of-state manager from FL though, who prevented the cost from escalating out of control to $2-$3 billion, never finishing, and bankrupting the City of San Jose.) https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2020/news20200519 https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2020/news20200519 In addition, the VTA stopped their Campbell extension 2 stops before the Netflix campus, so it's useless. Again, there's an existing right-of-way there.
- _qulr 6y agoHere in Wisconsin, there were federal subsidies available to build light rail connecting to Illinois and Minnesota, but our brilliant Republican Governor Scott Walker turned down the subsidies. That's why we don't have light rail. (He also turned down Medicare subsidies, because who needs health care amirite.) The very same brilliant Republican Governor Scott Walker did however offer massive state subsidies to Foxconn to build a factory here... which Foxconn never actually did. The whole thing turned out to be a giant scam. Taxpayer subsidized services for corporations? Hell yes! Taxpayer subsidized services for individuals? Hell no! The irony is that building public infrastructure would actually create jobs, which was the nominal justification for the factory.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoOne of my HR teachers told me stories that when she worked at some large manufacturing plant they would pay people to take buses to their plant from Milwaukee. Like rented out the bus and everything. They needed people so bad they paid them for the time traveled too. Public transport blows as an idea here simply cause everyone likes cars. As a fellow wisconsinite, I hate them with a passion. I can't be bothered with the maintenance and knowledge of it. Cars are just money pits. But cause the whole state is so sparsely laid out in every city, public transport has got another 1 people million per city to go before they start toying with it more.
- subpixel 6y agoThe article mentions, but ultimately downplays race. Race is the reason public transportation is unattractive to a millions of Americans. American cities and suburbs are designed to create areas where black people cannot and will not live. Sometimes this is done, as the article mentions, by rejecting bus and train plans from the word go. Other times this is done by building roads that purposefully do not accommodate buses, as was done on Long Island. And then of course there are the myriad gated communities with the word plantation in their name, which create a different form of deterrence. The reason the US sucks as building public transportation is that Americans do not want blacks in their neighborhood.
- hackern3 6y agoWhy would white people not want to live around black people?
- rayiner 6y agoThat’s a questionable inference at best. I live adjacent to one of the wealthiest majority-Black areas in the country (Maryland, east of DC: https://ggwash.org/view/79489/prince-georges-countys-belt-of-high-income-majority-black-census-tracts-really-is-unique https://ggwash.org/view/79489/prince-georges-countys-belt-of...). But there is no transit here either. Folks there don’t want to pay higher taxes to fund transit any more than anyone else. That view also fails to explain the costs of building transit in places that already have large minority populations. Why does it cost NYC 5-7x as much to build a unit length of subway as London or Paris? Why was the DC light rail such a money pit? Maryland is building a light rail between two high income DC suburbs. It will cost as much to build above-ground, not grade separated light rail along existing streets in the suburbs as it did for Denmark to build a fully automated, fully underground system of similar length under Copenhagen.
- subpixel 6y agoThere’s really nothing to infer - it’s in the public record. Keeping black people out of white neighborhoods (towns even) has been policy for generations in America. Including where you live. Real estate is devalued in Prince Georges County because its population is largely black. Why is it largely black? Because white flight. Public transportation in the US is inefficient because it is underutilized even where it exists (nyc notwithstanding). Riding a bus carries stigma that is racial as well as economic and this leads to transportation systems that few use, reinforcing a notion that they are wasteful and inefficient. The true metric for comparison is not what a public transportation system costs to build, but how many people per capita use it. That’s where Americans show their stripes. I’ve lived and ridden public transportation in Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, Texas, Germany, Japan and NYC. This is a sociological problem, not a technical or financial one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- karmakaze 6y agoThe main reason is because those in charge aren't really trying to make better 'public transportation'. The auotes is for for the connotation, public transportation isn't for the general public. It's for the public that don't drive, take limos, cabs or uber's. With that mindset where's the motivation or expectation to excel?