7 ms·
Compare your best estimates of land usage to the amount of land the US uses to grow corn for ethanol. Or compare it to the amount of land used for parking. Or
by epistasis 6y ago
Compare your best estimates of land usage to the amount of land the US uses to grow corn for ethanol.
Or compare it to the amount of land used for parking. Or for roads. Or for roofs of buildings.
I've never, not once, ever seen a comparison of this sort that sounded the least bit scary.
2. I'm a bit flabbergasted that you think we can scar nuclear production to what we need. We can't even scale nuclear production to hit replacement rate of our existing reactors. Nuclear does not scale, because it can not be built.
And I'm similarly flabbergasted that you think storage would hit scaling problems, when we build new factories for storage all the time, use new chemistries all the time to reduce the use of limited input components.
Storage production is growing at a massive pace, problems are getting solved all the time. Nuclear is shrinking all the time, gets more expensive all the time, and we can't even figure out basic concrete pours and welding. These industries are hugely contrasting, but I don't know how you can reach your conclusions when looking at the reality of storage and nuclear as they are in the real word.
- vkou 6y agoIt's not that nuclear cannot be built. It's that America is incapable of building... Pretty much anything in the 21st century. If the interstate system were to disappear tomorrow, for example, we simply wouldn't be able to rebuild it. It's not because concrete is some arcane technology that isn't cost effective, or doesn't work. It's because we just aren't very good at building things anymore.
- andrewzah 6y agoThat and we can’t displace black people anymore to build national highways thru residential areas. /s However I do agree. Our politicians prefer to wank over unimportant things instead of working on things that actually would benefit the people. And the government contracting system is horribly broken. There is no incentive to putting in the hard work to accomplish projects like before.
- jessaustin 6y agoThis isn't a great argument for building more nuclear plants. It might be an argument for hiring someone else to build them...
- throwawayboise 6y agoNew interstates are being built all the time. They are under construction today.
- vkou 6y agoYes, and they are built at absolutely ruinous costs.
- vlovich123 6y agoNuclear is actually intentionally crippled through legislation under over-hyped concerns over dirty bombs accidents (for the right and left politically inclined respectively). Nuclear can be done safe, efficient, cheap and at-scale. All it requires is to allow for the secondary market of spent fuel like was originally started when nuclear first starting to get rolled out. The security concerns can be handled in other ways than crippling nuclear from being self-sustaining I think.
- epistasis 6y agoCan you explain this a bit more? I don't see how these things could have helped any of the construction failures that have plagued all nuclear attempts. Operating costs are low for nuclear, it's the construction that is the problem.
- vbezhenar 6y agoPay money to Rosatom, they'll build nuclear plants for you. If US lost its nuclear competency, it does not mean that everyone else lost.
- YarickR2 6y agoCorrect answer. Floating nuclear power plant recently went operational , supplying arctic city with electricity ; it was built in two years, top to bottom. I wonder if couple of those in the Gulf of Mexico could've secured oil refineries' energy supply, allowing grid operators to divert more conventionally generated power to residential areas, diminishing blackouts
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoThe floating power plants from Rosatom are like 70 megawatt, a pittance vs the blackouts Texas saw. The root problem in Texas was insufficient winterization of the grid, caused by the incentives of their energy market approach. This would have still been the case even if Russia had 100 reactors floating off the Texas coast ready to hook up. There's significant latency in oil supply chains. Weeks if not months. Keeping a refinery online does not somehow keep a power plant online or the lights on in the cities in the proximate sense. Oil refineries are irrelevant to what happened.