4 ms·
> That's a great cherry-picked example I consider it reasoning from the limit case - obviously the existence of a market is not sufficient to prove that societ
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> That's a great cherry-picked example
I consider it reasoning from the limit case - obviously the existence of a market is not sufficient to prove that society has decided it is good, as the counter-example of the market in murder shows. Nothing more behind that statement and I think that markets are often a powerful tool.
> What moral framework do you suggest that we inflict upon all of humanity?
You can't escape "inflicting" a moral stance on the world. In the hypothetical world where the one has $200 billion and the remainder have $1, perhaps the government is not "arbitrating standards of morality", but if they make it illegal for the 7 billion to steal from the one person who has $200 billion, they are taking an ethical stance and "inflicting" it on the rest of the world.
We're a socially cooperative species - obviously we need a way to govern the form of those interactions, even in order to have a functioning market in things.
- generalizations 6y ago> You can't escape "inflicting" a moral stance on the world. Only if you start from the assumption that such things as bitcoin mining ought to be regulated in the first place. You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority. I'm arguing that involving a governmental authority to arbitrate morality is a can of worms that really doesn't need to be opened here. > Nothing more behind that statement Fair enough, I thought you meant to take that statement farther than you did.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority. So it's cool if I go to someone and take their bitcoins from them at gunpoint? Or start Mafia 2.0 and create my own protection racket here in SF?
- jcpham2 6y agoYour crime, your time.
- jfk13 6y ago> You're right - we are a 'socially cooperative species', and we're good at it. Leave us alone to cooperate and don't invoke some government authority. Isn't "some government authority" exactly how we as a species go about "socially cooperating" on a larger scale?
- ub99 6y agoI don’t understand - it’s like we have to repeat the same mistake over and over again. What industries have historically successfully self-regulated for the benefit of the society at large? Regulations and government involvement is why we don’t live in a slave society with a handful of militaristic barons.