2 ms·
The textbook used in a digital electronics design course I took in college in the early '80s ended with a section called "The Engineer as Dope Pusher". It gave
by tzs 6y ago
The textbook used in a digital electronics design course I took in college in the early '80s ended with a section called "The Engineer as Dope Pusher".
It gave an example of clothes dryers. The way most clothes dryers worked at the time is that you told them how long to run and how hot to get. The "how long to run" part was handled by a simple mechanical clock mechanism. You turned a dial to indicate how long you wanted it to run. Thus directly set the clock. You started the dryer, the clock ticked down, the dial moved back toward the original position, and when it got there the dryer stopped.
Those clock mechanism designs were several decades old. They were mass produced, very reliable, very cheap, and when one did broke the repairperson could easily replace it with one from a different manufacturer. Different models might have different mounting brackets, but it was easy for a repairman to improvise something if they didn't happen to have one on hand with the right bracket.
They were also extremely easy for consumers to use.
But they are also boring for the dryer designers. So there were dryer designers out there, the author said, who were starting to design their new dryers with digital timers.
Digital was exciting. The engineer got to play with microprocessors which were new at the time. They got to design printed circuit boards, a power supply for the digital electronics [1], a display, a keypad for input. They got to play around with programming the microprocessor.
But to the consumer that digital dryer control wasn't better. It didn't offer any functionality that the mechanical clock interface did not. It had a much worse interface usually. It was less reliable. It cost more, so when it did break the consumer was looking at a more expensive repair, and a slower repair since the repairperson had to get that specific control unit.
The point was that the engineer should not let their desire to play around with new and fun things take priority over delivering the best solution to the customer. There are places where digital is better than the old way--if you want to play with digital you should work on those projects, not shove digital into places where it is worse.
[1] The mechanical timers were either powered by a spring that was wound up when you turned the dial, or a simple electric motor that just needed a transformer to power it from the AC and maybe a rectifier.
- dwb 6y agoAgreed, but don't conflate "solving business problems" with "best solution for the customer".
- Jommi 6y agoMore like an example of short-sightedness. Sure mechanical spring is better but having digital interface allows for complex dryer timing logic and optimisations.
- tzs 6y agoIf someone decides to make a dryer with complex logic and optimizations then digital would be the better solution for the consumer. The author was talking about dryers that had no functionality beyond what the ones with the mechanical timers had. They were digital just because that was more interesting to the dryer engineer.
- Jommi 6y agoYet we never would move up to dryers with amazing QoL improvements if we first didnt move up to digital dryers instead of mechanical timers. Thats what I imply here.