2 ms·
SLS made no sense from the moment it was proposed.
by pfdietz 6y ago
SLS made no sense from the moment it was proposed.
- Spartan-S63 6y agoIt did from the perspective of saving STS jobs.
- avmich 6y agoBut saving jobs by itself doesn't bring much benefits. Maybe if you're going to use that experience in a soon to come follow-up project... which with NASA could be very much not guaranteed.
- bumby 6y agoBenefits to whom? If you assume it’s to benefit NASA, but I think this statement is meant to speak to benefits to politicians
- pfdietz 6y agoGraft and corruption make sense to politicians. They don't make sense to the country as a whole. Public Choice Theory offers explanations, not justifications.
- bumby 6y agoI’m not necessarily disagreeing, but was taking a less cynical perspective. I was talking about the “self licking ice cream cone” in that politicians will protect their constituents interest whether it makes sense for the country or not.
- eloff 6y agoProbably true, but I'm trying to be generous. It's been a huge political boondoggle.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThere's a difference between "it's twice as expensive as the alternatives" and "it's 20x as expensive as the alternatives", though. SpaceX has upended the cost analysis on stuff like this.
- pfdietz 6y agoThe issue is that there was no program using SLS that made any sense. It was so expensive it could not be used. The only way forward is reducing launch costs. SpaceX did that, but if that had not happened SLS still would have been pointless.