3 ms·
By their own admission these chemicals are everywhere, and yet by a lot of measures people are more healthy and living longer than before... I feel just a bit s
by userbinator 6y ago
By their own admission these chemicals are everywhere, and yet by a lot of measures people are more healthy and living longer than before... I feel just a bit suspicious.
- happytoexplain 6y ago>and yet by a lot of measures people are more healthy and living longer than before This argument doesn't make sense to me without something more specific. Just because such high level concepts like "health" and length of life continue to increase, that doesn't invalidate any particular malady.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wittyreference 6y agoThere are multiple variables in play at one time. Like, ... every other thing in medical science and public health. It would probably be more helpful if someone went ahead and just looked closer at the activity of the compound of interest, and saw what impact it had in isolation. We could call these people researchers, in honor of their tenacity in scrutinizing and re-scrutinizing their work and the work of others. And when their work impacts the health of the many, maybe we could use mass communications technology to share it. Pie in the sky, I know.
- userbinator 6y agoMy main objection is to the "must be banned immediately" part. That's totally alarmist and unnecessarily inflammatory.
- thefounder 6y agoWhy should we wait?
- wittyreference 6y agoWe've been collecting increasingly reliable data on the harmful effects of pthalates on human development for at least two decades. How much data must accrue, and how harmful must it be, for an immediate ban to not be alarmist?
- JSeymourATL 6y agoTangential: US life expectancy drops a year in pandemic, most since WWII > https://apnews.com/article/us-life-expectancy-huge-decline-f4caaf4555563d09e927f1798136a869 https://apnews.com/article/us-life-expectancy-huge-decline-f...
- wiml 6y agoOne possibility is that people are healthy because we are increasingly paying attention to widespread low-level pollution (like phthalates, lead, asbestos, etc.)
- pvaldes 6y ago> people are more healthy and living longer than before If we talk about US I'm unsure about that. Specially the first part of that statement, it seems that at least one of each three Americans are obese. The best part when _again_ some people studying _put very important thing for the public interest here_ ... is done by volunteers spending their own money.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tasty_freeze 6y agoThat would be a great point if health and longevity were controlled by a single variable, and that variable happened to be phthalate intake. But we know health and longevity are controlled by a dizzying number of factors that interact, so your suspicion, right or wrong, isn't justified by your observation. For example, far fewer people smoke today than did 30 years ago; medical treatments are more advanced than they were 30 years ago. And finally, phthalates were in widespread use 30 years ago too. Phthalates may have been harming us all along but those other improvements still result in an overall improvement in health and longevity.