3 ms·
> Why don’t bands deserve to be paid for their product? The presentation suggests that Metallica goes unpaid for their product. I suspect there are many fat ba
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
> Why don’t bands deserve to be paid for their product?
The presentation suggests that Metallica goes unpaid for their product. I suspect there are many fat bank deposits that indicate otherwise.
What I feel is more important is that the assertion obfuscates the primary motivation in play. Wealthy and powerful copyright interests want to control what customers get to do with the product they purchase. This government-granted privilege isn't one that's enjoyed by the vast bulk of producers.
Worse, copyright gatekeepers have twisted the constitutional purpose of copyright - from encouraging the progress of science and the useful arts - into a pampered entitlement of never-ending profit.
- lawnchair_larry 6y ago> Wealthy and powerful copyright interests want to control what customers get to do with the product they purchase. No, this is not a story of the evil capitalist overlord oppressing the little guy. Save the hero narrative. Even the broke bands (which is most of them) want people to pay them for their work. The good news is there are actually a lot of them who don’t, and that’s their personal decision. You’re allowed to take it for free if they set their price at zero, but you’re not allowed to set their price at zero for them.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> Even the broke bands (which is most of them) want people to pay them for their work. Broke bands aren't who are paying legislators for ever-racheting copyright laws - each of which comes at the public's expense and further betrays the bargain between copyright holders and the public. and - Corruption fueled copyright laws tend to favor powerful, wealthy gatekeepers (by design). For everyone else there are far better methodologies to making a living. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120210/02273417726/how-being-more-open-human-awesome-can-save-anyone-worried-about-making-money-entertainment.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120210/02273417726/how-b...