9 ms·
90k packages are stolen in NYC every day – How one building fought back
- michaelbuckbee 6y agoWow that 43% of people who get online orders have experienced a theft seems super high to me. I'm trying to think of the lowest tech solution to this that would work. Maybe plexiglass lockboxes that are secured to the floor but left unlocked. Package delivery workers can put them in the boxes with little effort (important or won't be done) but only residents can open them up. Just enough to deter casual/opportunistic theft.
- me_me_me 6y agoThere isn't a solution really. Drivers are paid too little to care and have to deliver too many packages - leading to mistreatment of a package and lack of time to knock and wait for the owner. You could maybe have an option to register with distributors to not deliver your packages but keep them in the centers and only send you a not that you can collect package. But that kind of defeats a purpose of delivery :/
- fatnoah 6y ago>There isn't a solution really. Drivers are paid too little to care and have to deliver too many packages - leading to mistreatment of a package and lack of time to knock and wait for the owner. The ultimate highlight of this was a rug that UPS told me was delivered to my home. I received the alert on my phone and went outside to try to find it, but couldn't. I wasn't too worried because it wasn't unusual for UPS to report packages as delivered up to 30 minutes before they actually arrived. (Yes, this happened more than once) About 25 minutes later, I received a call from a gentleman a couple miles away. He was washing his car when the UPS truck sped by and hit a bump, causing my rug and a couple boxes to fall out of the back and into the middle of the road (it was one of the hottest, most humid days of the year). Fortunately, my phone number was on the shipping label.
- me_me_me 6y ago> causing my rug and a couple boxes to fall out of the back and into the middle of the road I though that only happens in the movies xD Or when buying stolen goods ("I swear man, it fall out of the back and into the middle of the road").
- fatnoah 6y agoI didn't even think of that. I guess stuff can literally fall off the truck!
- JohnTHaller 6y agoIn NYC you MUST register with USPS, UPS, and FedEx for delivery notifications. Delivery folks won't even bother ringing your bell and will often skip getting the signature even if it's required because they face constant pressure to deliver more in less time from the company. You need the electronic notification to know it's there and you need to get there immediately as thieves will follow delivery trucks/personnel around the neighborhood, stealing after each delivery.
- jrockway 6y agoThat hasn't been my experience. Everyone rings the bell except the USPS, who has a key to let themselves in. Many years ago, something being shipped by Lasership means you'd never get it, but they seem to have improved on that front. Anecdotal but I don't think packages get stolen in my neighborhood. I occasionally read Nextdoor and it never comes up. And my neighbors complain about everything.
- JohnTHaller 6y agoIt happens in my neighborhood regularly. It gets talked about on Nextdoor and on our subreddit often as well. It varies by block. Ours has been better lately but was a lot worse mid-2020.
- nobody9999 6y ago>In NYC you MUST register with USPS, UPS, and FedEx for delivery notifications That's just not true. As long as you have a tracking number, you can get delivery notifications without registering simply by requesting them on the relevant websites. I do that all the time. >You need the electronic notification to know it's there and you need to get there immediately as thieves will follow delivery trucks/personnel around the neighborhood, stealing after each delivery. That may happen where you live, but where I live (10025), that's not even close to the truth. There are often at least a half-dozen packages in my lobby (no doorman) at any given time and package theft is rare. We had a problem with that a few years back, but when I called the police and then loudly told the likely perpetrators (and reminded them about the video cameras in the lobby), that stopped pretty quickly. Want to do the same? Here's a shocking idea -- talk to your neighbors. Make sure there's surveillance (not that invasive Amazon Ring stuff) where packages are left, and make sure folks know they're being watched. What's more, it would only take one person to be arrested (because the thieves are likely people you see every single day) for this to make it stop in your building. Having a community makes a difference. Perhaps you should try it sometime?
- cushychicken 6y agoThat's just awful. I'm guessing Amazon lockers are fairly rare in NYC. I'm also guessing that it's rare that you can get a post office box/UPS store box in NYC, what with real estate being so expensive.
- thatguy0900 6y agoYou would think amazon lockers would be worth their weight in gold to amazon if it really has to reship stolen packages that much
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoOne wonders how long it will be before people simply start trying to open package lockers, e.g. with a battery powered angle grinder like bike thieves use. Sure, I suppose there are cameras on these lockers, but from news reports about package theft in the US, it seems like many of these thieves don’t care at all if their face is caught on camera.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoBased on my personal experience, these aren't professional thieves casing buildings with an Ocean's 11 crew. They're opportunistic, and will just attempt to enter a building if they can. They're not going to invest in an angle-grinder - a loud, attention-grabbing device - to gamble getting a six-pack of toilet paper and a vacuum hose. Especially not when you can enter a building just by going into the lobby and buzzing every apartment by running your hand down the call box until someone finally buzzes you in.
- pmcollins 6y agoSeems like the NYPD could catch dozens of thieves per day just by setting up sting operations with honeypots around the city.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat's the punishment? What are the odds of stopping them from doing it again? They'll just go back to stealing packages after spending a few days in jail. People who do these things frequently have no reason not to because the available punishments do not affect them.
- ufmace 6y agoOh they resisted eh? Exactly how? I'm not seeing much of anything in this article, besides getting a security camera reactivated so that they can see a video of who stole their stuff, which will never be followed up on anyways. I want to feel sorry for them, but I cannot forget that this is exactly what they asked for. In all probability, the actual people in this building they featured, that is. They got the state to abolish bail for people arrested for these "low-value property crimes". They elected DAs who promised to not prosecute them at all. They are probably even now campaigning to "abolish the police" entirely. In case anyone was wondering, they've also published articles declaring that yes they really do want to literally abolish the police and it is not at all a euphemism for some kind of reform. What they're seeing now is exactly what they asked for. Now they want to whine about their packages getting stolen? Too bad, wake me when the start advocating for actual enforcement against brazen theft.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xsmasher 6y agoWhat indicates these residents are part of the monolithic "they" that you lay out?
- benjohnson 6y agoIt’s statistical likely - the voting patterns of wealthy urban residents of NYC have remained constant in recent years.
- ufmace 6y agoThe story certainly didn't mention any attempt by any of them to advocate or help campaign for increased enforcement, prosecution, and restoring bail requirements for such crimes. When nearly all visible agitation is in favor of zero enforcement or consequences against the crimes they're complaining about being the victim of, it's kind of counterproductive to not push back.
- zeppelin101 6y agoI'm actually a little bit shocked that people are this naive. You should try to ship virtually everything to either an Amazon locker or a workplace or somewhere with a concierge. This theft of packages is absolutely rampant throughout every major metropolitan in the U.S. If your package is going to be dropped off casually somewhere, it had better have inexpensive contents.
- hu3 6y agoSorry but no, this rate of package theft is not the norm around the globe and law abiding citizens should not have to take such measures. Government needs to find a solution. And no, people are not this naive. Don't belittle them. That's just victim blaming.
- hshshs2 6y agothe solution already exists, you pick up your package from a monitored location... what the hell is the government going to do to beat that? in my neighborhood I just have to go to the local bodega to pick things up
- zeppelin101 6y agoI agree that this isn't how things should be, but it clearly is. And with the way our politics are going in Democrat-run cities, I don't see this problem getting any better, unless we'll start to have even more places to ship our packages to. Right now, Amazon has clearly done the best job with this. My guess is that one "solution" to this might be a semi-public set of lockers - much like Amazon's, but available to other retailers and even to individuals. I personally think that America is slowly becoming more like Brazil and South Africa. But we'll just have more elaborate rationalizations for all of these changes.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoAre Republican-run cities better managed?
- smilekzs 6y agoRoughly in the same timeline, porch pirates have been rampant in my community (in the SF Bay Area nevertheless!) and causing a lot of headache for me and my neighbors (at least those in our chat group). It seems to me that these CRIMINALS face little to no consequences here, both absolute and relative to the damage they are causing. The so-called police is willing and capable to do exactly nothing about it. Any confrontation either hurts the resident, or puts the (otherwise perfectly legal) resident under legal trouble... Which is weird, because this effectively means that the victim faces more risk than even the perpetrator, just by the virtue of having an address and living a proper, productive life! In the end I can't help but feel they are the predator and we are the prey. And the rest of the society is, uh, pretty content with the status quo? BTW: Would the Singapore system ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore ), properly enforced, act as a credible deterrence?
- 77777 6y agoDidn't expect that last line ("BTW") but to be honest, I think something like that is the only solution. If you look at society 400-500 years ago, brutal punishment of this variety was the norm: theft in Restoration England was often enough met with hanging. Since then, the penalties for theft and other "petty" crimes have been reduced, to the point that now theft has been completely normalized. People complained, for example, when charges against Amy Cooper were dropped in New York, but the fact is that you can get arrested hundreds of times in New York, and your charges will always be dropped, for basically any charge, theft, assault, domestic violence, you name it, they drop it. There is a total unwillingness by people in power to inflict punishment on people who punish ordinary citizens by committing crimes against them, sending the signal committing crime is not at all, in fact, criminal, but normal, expected and acceptable behavior. Non-criminal people will flee such environments en masse or become criminals themselves. The result will be lawless cities that blowhards like Trump talk about but do nothing to fix, and only make worse. I am not saying we should go back to hanging people for theft. But we do need to figure out how to punish people without maintaining the Prison Industrial Complex. We need to figure out what is a crime (theft) and not a crime (drug use), we need to provide social services, food, shelter to poor people. We MUST provide education and opportunities to people. But if crime goes unpunished, perhaps in an asymmetric manner like caning, the lawlessness we're seeing today will grow much, much worse and make basic life unlivable in places that were once and still maybe are the pinnacles of civilization, like New York. It will destroy us.
- barnacled 6y agoEDIT: Removed as getting downvoted into oblivion...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 6y agoPaywalls have been discussed over and over, enough to have its own FAQ entry. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://hn.algolia.com/?query=paywalls%20by:dang&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=paywalls%20by:dang&dateRange=a...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AdrianB1 6y agoFor rents upwards of $4000 I would expect some minimal investment in better building security.
- padraic7a 6y agoThat seems like an insane level of theft. But also really negligent landlords. It really shouldn't be possible to access resident's belongings with a plastic card.
- MilnerRoute 6y agoI feel like that headline should really be, "how one building tried to fight back." Because it ends with the package thefts still ongoing, and the author of the article resigned to their continuing.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoYes, I have no idea why this is on HN - not tech related, and basically no actual content except for a feel-bad story with no conclusion.
- morninglight 6y agoI lived in a LARGE apartment building for many years. We had some package theft, so I let it be known that I would accept deliveries for other residents during the day. (I worked nights.) I did not charge for this service - but I did accept tips. It worked out very well.
- haspoken 6y agohttp://archive.is/0FgHs http://archive.is/0FgHs
- siliconpotato 6y agoMaybe the residents could collectively hire someone sit in the lobby to collect and look after deliveries.