2 ms·
In which case, you see yourself not as a professional, but as a minion. That's fine, but understand that it works differently for other people. Consider a doct
by wpietri 6y ago
In which case, you see yourself not as a professional, but as a minion. That's fine, but understand that it works differently for other people.
Consider a doctor, for example. A hospital can hire them and give them orders. But they see themselves as having a duty to the patient and to society. If something isn't right, they will surely say so internally first. But if harm continues, they absolutely will raise a ruckus, up to and including talking publicly.
That's not them being a "trouble maker". That's them being professionals, not bootlickers. Whether or not the hospital administrator puts that in the job description, everybody understands it's part of the deal.
I would note that real engineers have the same sort of duty: "Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public." https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engineers-become-whistleblowers/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engin...
I think it's a little sad that many software developers see themselves as minions, but hold out hope that one day we'll become professionals.
- JamesBarney 6y agoIt's weird that use the term and minion and professional in a way such that the farther you go up the org chart the more "minion like and unprofessional" they get. With the CEO probably being the most minion like and least profressional.
- wpietri 6y agoNot at all. The CEO isn't doing whatever the powerful tell him. Neither are high-level execs. See Locke and Spender's "Confronting Mangerialism" for a good breakdown of the game they're playing. Its line workers, and maybe first-level managers that are the most minion-like, the ones who most believe that their job is to follow orders make their boss look good, without regard to impact, value, or ethics.