3 ms·
How much is a wrongful termination going to cost them? Max a couple million? How much do they lose from the PR of gutting their AI ethics division of people w
by monocasa 6y ago
How much is a wrongful termination going to cost them? Max a couple million?
How much do they lose from the PR of gutting their AI ethics division of people who didn't toe the company line? More than a couple million easily, IMO.
I can see them being just willing to take the loss on the wrongful termination if they get to smear her on the way out and think they can get her to accept a deal in the end that comes with a more stringent NDA.
- JamesBarney 6y ago> How much do they lose from the PR of gutting their AI ethics division of people who didn't toe the company line? More than a couple million easily, IMO. Very few people really care about this issue enough to permanently change their behavior. My family was pretty upset about Gebru firing but when I visited all of their computers were still defaulting to search Google instead of Bing or duckduckgo. A lawsuit where they lied about firing someone is much worse PR and then the truth about why they fired her would get out and it would be much worse. Also she hasn't denied the accusation.
- monocasa 6y ago> A lawsuit where they lied about firing someone is much worse PR and then the truth about why they fired her would get out and it would be much worse. We already know they lied about firing Gebru. > Also she hasn't denied the accusation. The fact that she's not blasting the press yet isn't a point against her.
- JamesBarney 6y agoDid google lie about a verifiable fact in the Gebru firing? I would doubt that. If you could find something like that I would seriously reconsider how I viewed Google's statements. But right now what we have is Google: we fired her for exfiltrating data Source close to meg as reported by newspaper: she wrote a script to exfiltrate data related Gebru Meg: no comment And your conclusion from this is Google is lying and she didn't exfiltrate data?
- monocasa 6y ago> Did google lie about a verifiable fact in the Gebru firing? I would doubt that. If you could find something like that I would seriously reconsider how I viewed Google's statements. They literally denied firing her to begin with, stating that they had instead had simply accepted her resignation. > ... And your conclusion from this is Google is lying and she didn't exfiltrate data? No I'm saying there's probably more information that we're missing that completely changes the circumstances (as was the case if you only looked at Google's statements on Gebru's firing). The word on the street is that she saw a wrongful termination coming and made backups of emails to discuss with her lawyers.
- JamesBarney 6y ago> They literally denied firing her to begin with, stating that they had instead had simply accepted her resignation. Gebru sent a conditional resignation(ultimatum) letter to Google. Google rejected those conditions and accepted her resignation. Whether or not you count that as resigned or fired is a definitional issue. But legally there are many jurisdictions that consider an ultimatum letter a resignation. The general rule has been "Would a reasonable person who read this letter conclude they had the intention of quitting if their conditions were not met?". And Gebru's letter really made it seem like she has every intention of quitting if her conditions were not met. So this is definitely not lying in an easily verifiable way. > No I'm saying there's probably more information that we're missing that completely changes the circumstances (as was the case if you only looked at Google's statements on Gebru's firing). This is probably true, I'm not saying we know the whole story. I'm arguing that it is highly probably(>90%) she exfiltrated data from Google. > The word on the street is that she saw a wrongful termination coming and made backups of emails to discuss with her lawyers. This might be entirely possible, but this also gave them reason to terminate her so it seems like a very bad move.
- monocasa 6y ago> But legally there are many jurisdictions that consider an ultimatum letter a resignation. California is not one of those jurisdictions. She was fired. That is a verifiable fact. > This might be entirely possible, but this also gave them reason to terminate her so it seems like a very bad move. Unless she was working under the assumption that they already were going to fire her.