4 ms·
I suppose that depends on whether you think an "Ethical AI" group's job is as window dressing or to actually make an ethical impact. If the former, then they p
by wpietri 6y ago
I suppose that depends on whether you think an "Ethical AI" group's job is as window dressing or to actually make an ethical impact.
If the former, then they probably shouldn't be doing it in the first place; PR people are cheaper and more tractable. If the latter, then there's only so long you can ask good people to stay quiet. Enabling ethical failure is also an ethical failure.
Your analogies don't really work, I'm afraid. The job of corporate lawyers isn't to force some sort of ethical or legal standard. It's to give confidential advice so a company can do what it wants without anybody going to jail. Accountants do maintain a standard that is quasi-ethical, but they do it by controlling their own work. Auditors are closer to the Ethical AI relationship, but they're specifically external, so as to avoid the conflicts of interest in Google trying to police itself. And both accountants and auditors drop a dime on people all the time, and even have protection under law for doing so: https://www.accountingtoday.com/whistleblower https://www.accountingtoday.com/whistleblower
- solveit 6y agoI think the one thing both sides can agree on is that there should be whistleblower protections enshrined in law for people reporting ethics breaches. (I'm not going to try and suggest how it should be implemented, that's legitimately difficult)
- prepend 6y agoNo one in this scenario reported an ethics breach right? So how would it apply? There are whistleblower laws now but they apply to illegal actions.
- wpietri 6y agoThe heart of the matter is what the ethics experts see as an attempt to suppress criticism of ethical problems with Google's technology. So yes, it's very much an ethics breach. Whistleblowing need not be only about crime. It can just be about harm. [1] Indeed, with new technologies, regulation often has yet to be written, so whistleblowing can only be about harm. [1] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engineers-become-whistleblowers/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engin...
- prepend 6y agoI think that’s the disagreement. Dean said in his letter that the paper didn’t address relevant literature related to the subject that the authors weren’t aware of. To me it doesn’t seem that the reason is that it besmirched Google, but that it wasn’t complete. Also the article wasn’t an ethics breach type of article and internal so I’m not sure what the legal protection would be. I think if the employees had some evidence of illegal activity then they would be protected. If this paper would be considered an ethics breach then I don’t think there should ever be relevant protections.
- wpietri 6y agoYou seem to be conflating ethics and legality. The two are only hazily related. And yes, of course the executives who hired ethicists to make the company look good disagree with the ethicists on what constitutes good ethics. But your notion that "No one in this scenario reported an ethics breach" is incorrect. We can't of course know the truth of the matter, because Google insists on keeping relevant facts hidden. But unless clear evidence shows otherwise, I'm going to believe the ethics professionals, not the executives whose identity and financial success are strongly bound up with making their company look good.
- JamesBarney 6y ago> I suppose that depends on whether you think an "Ethical AI" group's job is as window dressing or to actually make an ethical impact. 1. You can make an ethical impact without applying external pressure. Usually through internal channels. That is their expectations when they hire you. 2. Do you really think "apply external pressure via bad publicity on companynwhen necessary leaking internal documents" was in their job responsibilities?
- wpietri 6y agoPoint 1 depends on the internal channels. If you have never had the experience of management not listening to you, I congratulate you on your luck and/or your youth. As to point 2, I think that if Google didn't put "make a public stink if necessary" in the job description itself, they should have known it was part of the deal. You can't hire people for their independence and their ethics and then not expect them to be independent and ethical.
- JamesBarney 6y agoI've definitely had management not listen to me. But I wouldn't share that information publicly in order to get them to coerce them into making the right call. And if I did I definitely wouldn't expect to be working there for long. Should have known that they were hiring people they would later consider trouble makers is a very different goal post than part of the job description.
- wpietri 6y agoIn which case, you see yourself not as a professional, but as a minion. That's fine, but understand that it works differently for other people. Consider a doctor, for example. A hospital can hire them and give them orders. But they see themselves as having a duty to the patient and to society. If something isn't right, they will surely say so internally first. But if harm continues, they absolutely will raise a ruckus, up to and including talking publicly. That's not them being a "trouble maker". That's them being professionals, not bootlickers. Whether or not the hospital administrator puts that in the job description, everybody understands it's part of the deal. I would note that real engineers have the same sort of duty: "Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public." https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engineers-become-whistleblowers/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-engin... I think it's a little sad that many software developers see themselves as minions, but hold out hope that one day we'll become professionals.
- D13Fd 6y agoForcing the company to comply with legal standards is often literally the job of a corporate attorney in an employment or compliance department. And the primary concern isn't to avoid "going to jail," it's avoiding civil liability (for employment) or regulatory action (for compliance). Offering guidance on ethical behavior helps to avoid both of those issues. Whistleblower statutes are an enforcement mechanism that provide cover (and sometimes motivation) to report or disclose ethical violations. But they are more of an escape valve for truly extraordinary situations, as opposed to the day-to-day guidance that professionals provide.
- wpietri 6y ago> Forcing the company to comply with legal standards is often literally the job of a corporate attorney in an employment or compliance department. Compliance departments may include attorneys, but plenty of people aren't. The force comes not because of their attorney-ness, but because they're part of a department tasked with enforcement. Lawyers in general definitely are not at a company to enforce the law. > And the primary concern isn't to avoid "going to jail," Allow me to introduce you to the notion of hyperbole.