2 ms·
> There’s also the question of why the PLA would bother to assign an active duty soldier This is a real reach; her non-fictitious employer was the Air Force Ge
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> There’s also the question of why the PLA would bother to assign an active duty soldier
This is a real reach; her non-fictitious employer was the Air Force General Hospital. Being employed by the military doesn't make you a soldier.
- refenestrator 6y agoThat's splitting hairs a little, unless she's legitimately a civilian. A military doctor could be referred to as a 'soldier', it's inaccurate but not wrong. My beef with the outrage on this is that she was studying 'treating brain disease' according to the justice department. This isn't a national security secret, and the occam's razor answer is she fudged the forms because she wanted to do the study sabbatical.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIf you think the category 'soldier' includes military doctors, the question "why would the military bother to assign an active duty soldier to a medical research project" makes absolutely no sense.
- refenestrator 6y agoYeah, I think we agree on the shape of what happened here. It's the new cold war, everything must be propagandized.
- zapita 6y agoThank you for answering my question instead of grandstanding. I had missed that crucial piece of information.
- refenestrator 6y agoI wasn't trying to grandstand, sorry if it sounded like it, and cheers. Really respect this post.
- zapita 6y agoHonestly I do it too. We get conditioned to assume every disagreement or question is in bad faith, because most of the time it is... Then we pounce and it becomes a self- fulfilling prophecy. In this case I didn’t read the original material carefully enough and made a fool of myself, so can’t blame anyone for assuming I was asking in bad faith. By the way I agree with you that this topic is over-propagandized, by both sides. It makes it extra difficult to have good faith debates over it.