3 ms·
"Low serotonin" was never the actual medical position on why antidepressants worked, it was marketing. The medical position is "we don't know why they work"; so
by astrange 6y ago
"Low serotonin" was never the actual medical position on why antidepressants worked, it was marketing. The medical position is "we don't know why they work"; some antidepressants actually lower serotonin (SNRI) and some increase it (SSRI) and they both seem to help.
Also, they take weeks to take effect which doesn't make sense for a neurotransmitter effect, since Adderall (which raises dopamine) works instantly for ADHD.
I've heard theories that just doing anything to your brain knocks it out of state enough to stop being depressed (eg psychadelics do this), or that antidepressants actually improve your sleep quality and your brain cleans itself up over time.
- m00x 6y agoWhere do you see SNRI lowers serotonin? It's a re-uptake inhibitor for both serotonin and norepinephrine which keeps your body from flushing our those chemicals which raises serotonin levels as long as production is stable. High doses of SNRI will contribute to Serotonin syndrome, which makes your argument hard to believe.
- astrange 6y agoOh, I was going from memory, so I guess that part's wrong. But there are effective antidepressants that aren't strongly based on the serotonin effects SSRIs have, like trazodone (weakly increases it) and especially ketamine (doesn't do it, works better than most antidepressants, works near-instantly instead of taking weeks).
- johnisgood 6y agoAnd I would like to add that ketamine has nothing to do with the monoamine hypothesis, it is an NMDA receptor antagonist. It has nothing to do with serotonin, dopamine, and noradrenalin. See my other comment about the growing interest in the glutamate system instead of serotonin and the like.
- texasbigdata 6y agoCan you please explain what seratonin syndrome is, particularly (like the above hypnosis / nlp split) where the edge of medical literature is? Highly interested, however for some reason was previously inclided to believe the phenomenon did not exist, akin to how adrenal fatigue can't be proven.
- maybelsyrup 6y ago> "Low serotonin" was never the actual medical position on why antidepressants worked, it was marketing. The medical position is "we don't know why they work"; some antidepressants actually lower serotonin (SNRI) and some increase it (SSRI) and they both seem to help. This just isn't the case. Maybe the more accurate thing to say is that there have been a few "medical positions" on this issue in the past six to eight decades, and "low serotonin" as well as "we don't know how they work" were both out there in the ether. But even that's not fully accurate, because you'd have to be pretty bold to argue that there wasn't a dominant "medical position" on the matter since biological psychiatry finished supplanting the Freudians for control of the field in the 1970s. The dominant position was the chemical imbalance theory, of which "low serotonin" was one of several variations trotted out over the years to both the public and the medical community. Psychiatry is one of the medical specialties most profoundly co-opted by pharmaceutical industry interests, and both research and clinical practice have been rife with the effects of this influence. You don't even have to appeal to systematic analyses of how profoundly poor the quality of psychiatric research is, or how much pharma ghostwrites those studies, or anything of the kind. You can just ask a researcher in cancer or in neurology; they'll happily tell you. To cleave the "medical position" from "marketing", as in your comment, elides what really happened: marketing decided what the medical position would be, and both doctors and the public mostly bought it.