5 ms·
> If that is the case, he still needs to be locked away for many years, because someone with that level of brokenness is not safe human society. Or rehabilitat
by wizzwizz4 6y ago
> If that is the case, he still needs to be locked away for many years, because someone with that level of brokenness is not safe human society.
Or rehabilitated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehabilitation_(penology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehabilitation_(penology)
> The effectiveness of Norway's methods is evident as they hold the lowest recidivism rate worldwide at 20% as of December 2014.
- selestify 6y agoThere's still that 20% that fails to be rehabilitated. This seems like it would be one of those cases.
- akiselev 6y agoI too feel that rehabilitation, not vengeance, should be the goal of the justice system but in this case, I think it's a moot point. This is an individual with the means and clear history of organizing and wielding violent armed groups which (I hypothesize) requires a level of emotional intelligence that justice systems are not equipped to rehabilitate by design. The ones that try to rehabilitate offenders naturally err towards giving people the benefit of the doubt in order to make the process fairer for the falsely accused which is very easily exploitable, especially for the well resourced. I think this individual presents a clear cut case where public safety is more important than the individual's right to rehabilitation post-conviction, in a way that even the worst civilian criminals like serial killers do not. There is just no way to reintegrate him to like a POW of an opposing nation in war or a rebel soldier who joined a movement - he was a primary instigator in the conflict and his enemy was the system he'd be rehabilitated into.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI don't think that your last statement is supported. Why isn't rehabilitation possible and why is it impossible that public safety can be ensured? You seem to assume that intelligent individuals are more difficult to rehabilitate but I see it is just as likely that the opposite the opposite. The burden of demonstrating public safety and rehabilitation should always be on the individual, but I don't see why that is impossible.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIt is a bit of a chicken-and-egg issue. People in Norway rarely grow up in totally deprived, violent conditions. Maybe they respond to rehabilitation efforts better, in the same way that a healthy person exhibits better wound healing than someone with diabetes 2nd type. One could make a practical experiment by dumping an assortment of, for example, Islamic State executioners into Norwegian prisons and watching how many of them return to their old habits, but Norwegians wouldn't probably want to try that.
- convolvatron 6y agohow much of that is due to basic social safety net? on the creek behind my workshop, thieves were running stolen copper. they would use boats to come up into businesses storage yards from the SF bay, then dump the copper in the creek. wait until they had a buy lines up and pull it up at their leisure. they were caught eventually. 5 years later and out on parole. and guess where they came first - back to the creek. no other way of making a living, no basic support. i think criminality becomes very different when its just a lifestyle choice and not the only way to provide for basic human needs. sure, focus on rehabilitation. but it doesn't matter if they throw you back on the street when you're out.
- belval 6y agoHe is not a felon convicted for illegal possession of a weapon or drug dealing, he's a warlord that killed a lot of people brutally. Presenting rehabilitation as a possible solution here is laughable and almost insulting to the memories of his numerous victims.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoI don't understand. Why would it be?
- belval 6y agoThe concept of rehabilitation makes plenty of sense when everyone agrees that we live in a society of inequalities and that everyone has various privileges which have a real impact on their financial situation. Someone that is poor might resort to stealing or even violence because the situation in which he evolves demands it to survive. I am completely on board with that and it makes sense. This man is a war criminal that that was directly and indirectly involved in murder and rapes. Worse, he actively enabled that behavior in his organization. Now in an exercise in empathy, put yourself in the shoe of someone who saw his entire family be massacred. You don't understand why theymight find it insulting to their suffering that this man is eventually allowed to walk free. To be clear you can disagree, but I really doubt that you don't understand.