8 ms·
This article makes zero sense to me. It's arguing that corporations are contributing data to OSM, but that this somehow... changes the proportion of what kinds
by crazygringo 6y ago
This article makes zero sense to me.
It's arguing that corporations are contributing data to OSM, but that this somehow... changes the proportion of what kinds of things OSM covers? That traditional users have added "hyperlocal features, such as a neighborhood bench or informal walking path" while coporations are adding "roads, buildings, and all other points of interest" and "a particular emphasis on improving road data".
How is this anything but good? As long as data is correct, the more data the better -- proportions are meaningless. Buildings and roads aren't taking away from benches and paths. And I'm pretty sure buildings and roads are benefiting all users anyways, no matter who contributes them.
I'm utterly baffled by what logic the author imagines this is a bad thing. The data is open, so it's not like corporations are winding up with exclusive ownership of anything.
So what's the problem...?
- londons_explore 6y agoI think the concern is big companies might get into governing positions and make decisions about the projects future... For example, they could decide to divert some efforts into a commercially licensed 'extended' dataset, or they could sign restrictive deals to get hold of 3d laser scan or satellite/aerial imagery that isn't so easy for volunteers to collect.
- crazygringo 6y agoThanks. I guess I just ask, is there any basis for that fear though? The OpenStreetMap Foundation's governance [1] isn't tied to who contributes data. Is there any evidence they are being "corrupted" in any way at all by corporations adding data? And like any open project, if its governance were captured by "bad guys", users can always fork it and "vote with their feet" since the data's open. If OSM really was being subject to a hostile board takeover by corporations then obviously that would be hugely newsworthy and concerning. But it's like the article is trying to stoke fears of this while presenting zero actual facts to support it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenStreetMap_Foundation#Governance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenStreetMap_Foundation#Gover...
- blihp 6y agoBased on previous large company involvement in 'open' projects, yes. It usually starts out fluffy and friendly and just 'wanting to help'. The large company (or companies) take on an increasingly large role eventually leading to taking on and then over governance... then it's often game over as far as the original intent of the project. By the time they are in the governance roles, the dissenters have typically already been marginalized and/or are gone. This is a very old strategy. Companies (especially the large, name-brand ones) aren't getting involved because they believe in the mission/objectives of OSM but rather that they see a strategic advantage in their involvement. They dip their toes in, get entrenched and then make their move. It's a lot faster and less expensive for them than trying to replicate what the project has produced.
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm very interested. Can you point to specific examples? And did the original contributors fork the project to a new successful initiative? Or if not, why not? I'm also curious why companies feel the need for this -- if the data is all open in the first place, why do the companies even need to bother? Why don't they just use the data directly? Without specific examples it's hard to understand.
- blihp 6y agoSpecifically related to the story, Apple has a rather troubled history as an Open Source 'contributor'. They tend to not contribute unless they need to and then prefer to run the show. They basically steamrolled KHTML with a fork of their own code a.k.a. WebKit (which they effectively control development of exclusively). Imagine them doing something like that to OSM... which they will if it ever suits their purposes. See most other Open Source projects Apple has been involved in... it's not pretty. So yeah, Apple playing a significant role in OSM should have alarm bells ringing in the heads of other contributors. That's not to say corporate involvement/sponsorship isn't important: it's vital to many important projects. The issue is when companies start trying to influence the projects beyond their technical needs and start trying to wrap their business model around them (a good indicator of that seems to be their involvement in governance) that the trouble starts. I think that's the concern being expressed about OSM.
- virgilp 6y agoThat would be a legitimate concern but the article focuses so much on stuff like "look how much edits Apple made!!" that it's really hard to tell if it was a concern for the author, at all; or if there are others (e.g. it spends about as much time talking about the governance concern as it talks about diversity in the governance body; so it's unclear if author is worried that companies might take over, or is just unpleased with the governance in general). Same as the parent poster, I'm baffled. This article makes no sense to me. If it had a point to made, it buried it in thousands of words of blabbering.
- damnafrica 6y agoIf we look very well at it we see Apple made the most contributions to map Africa. Who's going to complain about that? Google, maybe? I guess african roads don't suit the google maps cars.
- londons_explore 6y agoIt's also a curious business decision... Apple doesn't make much revenue in Africa, nor have many users there. Why direct all their mapping efforts there?
- joosters 6y agoNo-one said that Apple directs all (or even most, or even just a significant proportion) of their mapping efforts there. Should they ignore a continent?
- pydry 6y agoIt makes sense to commoditize their complement.
- astrange 6y agoDiversity and inclusion?
- xmprt 6y agoAfrica is the largest growing continent and just like China has been an extremely important market for many companies, so too will many developing African countries. Apple would love to be the market leader there and any headstart they can get will pay dividends in the future.
- closeparen 6y agoIs there really precedent for companies taking over open-source upstreams and turning them proprietary? I expect the corporate users appreciate the price & freedom at least as much as everyone else.
- oarsinsync 6y agoMySQL springs to mind
- closeparen 6y agoOracle took over MySQL as the acquirer of Sun, not as a heavy MySQL user with too much influence.
- bruce511 6y agoAlso mysql _sold_ their governance to Sun - it wasn't _taken over_.
- mpol 6y agoNot sure what "open-source upstream" means, but in software, there is the complaint that companies like Google can add a lot of complexity to software projects, which serves Google, but not the classic home user of Linux. That can make it effectively their own corporate project and drown out more casual developers.
- closeparen 6y agoThat much is true - direction and feature set. The accusation that seems weird is that companies would be motivated to make it proprietary just because they use it. At most, it seems like you’d get a niche for “enterprise” distributions with support contracts on the same stuff.
- Doctor_Fegg 6y agoIronically OSM is the opposite. The hobbyist mappers do bus routes and admin boundaries and mountain trails and all manner of complex stuff. The corporate mappers are really just interested in the most basic element: drivable roads.
- mpol 6y agoFor me this discussion is new, so I don't have good answers to these questions. One thing that happened when Pokemon Go got popular is that people (users) were conducting vandalism, in the sense that many pokemon figures were added to the main map of OSM. People have to work really hard to remove these, and they might burn out on this. There is already a lot of vandalism, like people adding their friends drinking shed, or whatever they think of as funny. Another thing that already happens with volunteers, is people thinking their working area is "their area", while no such concept exists. This can already give a lot of friction among volunteers. I can imagine if billions in money are at stake, big companies with a massive crowd of emplyees might want to really grab those working areas and drown out volunteers. If that gets a big problem, volunteers that were active for years might drop out.
- mpol 6y agoOh, one other thing. Many volunteers are maintaining and guarding hiking routes and cycling routes. These get damaged easily (I just did that yesterday myself) and these volunteers sometimes carry a big burden. The big companies don't have an interest in these routes "by the people, for the people", there is no money in that. If they get more often damaged, it will not be regarded as funny by these important long-lasting volunteers.
- abcanthur 6y agoIs this virtual or real damage? As in, the trail route is imperfect and misleading about the actual trail, or the trail is revealed via the map and others come and physical use damages the trail. The second reminds me of land owners sneakily putting "no trespassing" on land that is legally publicly accessible (I think this happened in Sausalito about a year ago)
- mpol 6y agoThere might be many situations, but I was mostly talking about virtual vandalism. When you edit points, lines or routes in the wrong way, they get damaged. The volunteers guarding these need to fix them themselves, which can be a burden and they can get emotional already. You can imagine how that goes when more damage gets done where the fixing is left for those volunteers. I don't know much about land-owners doing vandalism, often people try to communicate, sometimes this works out okay.
- ris 6y agoOne of the typical ways this manifests itself in reality is a dedicated local mapper adding or correcting a detail where they know that some common data sources are either wrong or out of date. At some point later a corporate mapper the other side of the planet working from imagery will come along and change it back to agree with the imagery they have, despite it being 4 years old. Local mappers get exhausted from the effort it takes to keep their patch from being broken and disenfranchised with their edits being drowned out by the noise of the corporate machine. A devils advocate answer of course, I'm personally on the fence on the issue.
- jlarocco 6y agoTo also play devil's advocate, that could happen with a non-corporate mapper on the other side of the world, too. The solution, I think, would be a mandatory date field specifying when the data was accurate, and only allowing updates with more recent data.
- MengerSponge 6y agoIt could happen, but it generally doesn't. That's the kind of thing that happens when someone is paid pennies per edit and given insufficient resources to guide those edits, which really only happens when someone points a hose of money at a contractor. I've long been a fan of a mandatory time field! Now to get Stack Overflow to implement it too :)
- ySteeK 6y agoThat, my friends, would be the first step for my dream to finally map historical data, like in the OHM, directly in the OSM without anyone feeling bothered by it.
- reaperducer 6y agoOne of the typical ways this manifests itself in reality is a dedicated local mapper adding or correcting a detail where they know that some common data sources are either wrong or out of date. At some point later a corporate mapper the other side of the planet working from imagery will come along and change it back to agree with the imagery they have, despite it being 4 years old It's happened to me. Not just on maps, but on Wikipedia.
- lucb1e 6y agoOSM contributor here: agreed with you, not sure what they're on about. All the sources are also old and known, with the newest references to the latest State of the Map conference. It's a long article with a lot of random historic fun facts, but I don't quite get the point.
- petre 6y agoThank you for the summary. I couldn't get past the popovers and the broken scroll to read the article.