6 ms·
Why is America getting a new $100B nuclear weapon?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bloqs 6y agoThe exhaustive number of articles, blog posts, twitter rants, instagram memes and comments which take <arbitrary military expenditure item> and then suggests that it is instead spent on <socially progressive item of choice> misses the fundamental issue here. Geopolitical facing military spending is often a facade. Particularly with such unprecedented success of western-hostile nations in either misinformation, or propaganda relating to the pandemic, I wouldn't be surprised at all if the US has a hard mathematical spending allocation not unlike Britain pre WWII - having a navy that must be AT LEAST twice the strength of the next nations. That allocation was probably established before the cold war. This is critical for the projection of power. MAD is a shaky concept that isnt oft guaranteed.
- noir_lord 6y ago> US has a hard mathematical spending allocation not unlike Britain pre WWII IIRC it was a two major war policy for a while not sure what it is now. https://www.britannica.com/topic/two-theatre-war https://www.britannica.com/topic/two-theatre-war
- tpetry 6y agoYes, these comparisons are kind of senseless. But spending so much money on atomic weapons is kind of bullshit! These are weapons, if ever used again will probably take-out humanity because if some of those are flying to you, you will answer with everything you have. In my opinion military spending should be reduced greatly. But if they want to invest so much invest them in technologies which may have more impact on other areas. Like the laser concept on navy ships.
- pdonis 6y ago> In my opinion military spending should be reduced greatly. But if the US does this unilaterally, its nuclear warheads are the last thing spending should be reduced on. It would be great if all countries mutually agreed to do this, but I won't hold my breath waiting for it to happen.
- codyb 6y agoThis is akin to the idea that Bitcoin's energy use is fine because of the fact there's no military to defend it, however... I don't think the world adopting BTC and crypto currencies would cause armed forces to disappear so the point seems a bit moot to me?
- pdonis 6y ago> This is akin to the idea that Bitcoin's energy use is fine because of the fact there's no military to defend it I don't see the connection here.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI don't remember where this observation actually comes from but it's been said that the Military Industrial Complex always prepares "for the last war". So it makes perfect sense that we are spending so much on established doctrine and neglecting the modern information/disinformation conflict.
- kube-system 6y ago> The exhaustive number of articles, blog posts, twitter rants, instagram memes and comments which take <arbitrary military expenditure item> and then suggests that it is instead spent on <socially progressive item of choice> misses the fundamental issue here. Not to mention, it's a false dilemma. The US is rich enough to spend $100 billion on a missile and $100 billion on whatever else it should be spent on. The CARES act was $2,200 billion. The PPP was $484 billion. The last appropriations bill added another $900 billion for COVID relief. The house is getting ready to vote on another $1,900 billion bill here by the end of the month. This missile is less than 2% of what I've just listed. We clearly have the money for dealing with problems when we choose to.
- giantg2 6y agoYou mean clearly have the ability to borrow money to deal with problems.
- nicoburns 6y agoGovernments borrowing money effectively just redistributes wealth as far as I can see.
- samatman 6y agoIndeed, and given the nature of the dollar as reserve currency, it's the only mechanism the US has to tax other countries.
- phkahler 6y agoNo, it's got long term consequences that have not fully come around yet. Government spending redistributes money and in some cases that's probably a good thing. In others not so much. But borrowing to do it is bad long term.
- codyb 6y agoMy understanding is a bit of inflation would actually be a good thing for the US at this point. A weaker dollar means exports are more competitive and imports are less desirable which would boost American exports. It's also a huge boon for the rest of the world which deals with dollars extensively. Finally, most economists seem to have come around to the fact that our national debt is sustainable and the economic activity is more valuable than the interest payments on it.
- pram 6y agoYes, the 'strategic' portions of our defense are basically the rock that keeps tigers away. They're more about credibility than anything else. It's easy to understand why they're perceived as a giant waste of GDP, considering that optimally they'd never get used.
- ApolloFortyNine 6y agoThe U.S hasn't built a new nuclear warhead in almost 30 years, any changes since have been modifying existing nuclear warheads. A new program had to happen eventually. Where's the teacher salary comparisons for the $1.9 trillion dollar stimulus package anyways. With that much money we could almost convert our country's entire energy production to green energy.
- zaphod4prez 6y agoOr we could have spent that "stimulus" on individuals or COVID treatment efforts, rather than e.g. $15billion to airlines that didn't need to be saved and that ended up firing workers anyways! If Delta failed its assets would be sold and a new airline would take its place... that's an area where the market does a great job so why fight it
- raziel2701 6y agoIt's not a new warhead, the article is covering the new delivery system. Warhead projects are all about updating the manufacturing processes in line with the stockpile stewardship mission of DOE.
- baybal2 6y agoThe logic of "drawing fire" is kind of self-defeating. What enemy would spend munitions on an empty silo, while knowing that the you already shot all your arsenal? With radar, and infrared satellites everywhere, attacking a second strike weapon makes no sense. Any attacker in sane mind will fully focus on offensive.
- typest 6y agoThe idea is that it is not an empty silo. The thinking is that if your opponent wants to launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike against you, they'll need to target all your nuclear missiles with theirs, to prevent you from retaliation. If you have lots of missiles spread out in otherwise non-strategic locations, you can make it harder for your opponent to preemptively strike you, as they'll have to destroy all these random missiles to prevent counter attack. In doing so, they would be failing to target densely populated areas, which would lower the efficacy of their attack. Not saying I agree or disagree with it. But, that's the logic, anyway.
- jandrese 6y agoI don't think even the US has harbored the insane notion that you could strike all of the missile silos and avoid retaliation. The operating principal for nuclear missiles is Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD). This goes double if nuclear submarines exist (they do). Plus nuclear bunkers are supposed to be hardened against nuclear strike. So they could absorb the hit and still launch. Nuclear weapons are actually pretty poor at destroying protected underground facilities. You need something completely different: a heavy piercing bunker buster bomb full of conventional explosives. Plus, even if you were magically successful in destroying all of your opponent's nukes without retaliation you've still completely wrecked the environment. Fallout and nuclear winter are still going to ruin your victory.
- chipsa 6y agoMutually assured destruction is not a policy. The actual US policy is assured destruction: use WMDs on us and we will destroy you, and e will posture or things to be able to assure that we can.
- raziel2701 6y agoIt's many things. One is obviously deterrence, but mostly it's a show. We're reminding the world that we hold the key to our mutual destruction, which interestingly leads to longer periods of peace (in a big picture kind of way). How many wars would the US have seen in the last 70 years if they didn't have nukes? They'd probably have been invaded by now and some US cities may not even exist or would be rebuilt very differently (maybe we'd have better infrastructure by now :) ). Things would be very different without nukes. We take them for granted, but shows like this are necessary to keep things in check, because an alternative reminder would be a detonation of one of these things, and with the exception of some lunatics, most don't want to see them go off. The other part is that these projects are pretty much jobs programs for the masses of engineers and phds that we keep cranking out without a very good idea of what to do with all this intellectual capital. It's a very expensive jobs program granted, and they serve the purpose of maintaining the military industrial complex. Could this money be better spent? Absolutely. Do we have a sufficient majority to vote for structural reforms? Nope. So bombs it is then until enough people vote against it.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoI'm not trying to nitpick, just curious about how this works? Some years pass, and the russians just forget that the US have nukes? Then they start planning an invasion, but cancel it after they read in the "new york times" about some modernization effort, and remember that the us still have nukes?
- raziel2701 6y agoIt's a display of power. We've been stuck in a certain mindset from the Cold War and habits are hard to break. Over time we've dialed back on the heat (we don't do live tests anymore for instance and we are not actively developing new warheads). But there's still a whole military industrial complex that is not going to go away anytime soon. So you do this new missile. It keeps people employed, it shallowly reminds other powers that we're still doing perfunctory defense stuff.
- samatman 6y agoAmerica was last invaded in 1812, so it's not at all clear to me that, absent nuclear weapons, it would have been invaded in the latter half of the 1900s. Their absence would have made a conventional war in Europe with the USSR more likely, and perhaps this would have lead to an invasion of Alaska. I don't see a scenario where any credible belligerent could have projected power into the US mainland. I do agree that the net effect of nuclear weapons has been less human death, including of US citizens. But invasion is farfetched.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI think throwing the "$100 billion over 50 years" number around is somewhat misleading without comparing to the cost of keeping Minuteman III alive for another 50 years. Most of that cost is gonna be maintenance/sustainment/operations, which we're paying already for with the current squadrons. And it's possible (although I wouldn't count on it) that a new system would be more maintainable than the existing one. For example if keeping Minuteman III alive would've required the US to spend a billion dollars to build a new 5.5" floppy drive factory, that would give GBSD an opportunity to recoup some of the R&D costs
- jacques_chester 6y agoOne of the arguments made is that land-based missiles should be retired entirely, because they are less effective and strategically riskier than submarines and bombers. Such a retirement would make the extension of Minuteman III moot.
- philipkglass 6y agoThe land based ICBM force has had little utility since submarine launched ballistic missiles reached maturity. SLBMs guarantee devastating retaliation if another nation initiates nuclear war. Bomber-delivered nuclear weapons offer flexibility including last minute re-targeting or mission abort. What does the land based ICBM force offer that bombers and submarines don't? Pork for rural areas and missile contractors, according to this article. I should have figured that out on my own sooner.
- gen3 6y agoThe article did mention how they are used to draw fire away from populous areas. I think that has value...
- mauvehaus 6y agoPerhaps, but what will all those survivors eat? Glow in the dark bread? The fact that the land is sparsely inhabited doesn't mean the densely inhabited parts of the country don't depend on it.
- hddu 6y agoHow many foreign controlled nuclear weapons are currently on us soil? Why spend billions developing rockets or stealth bombers when you can just load one up on a civilian boat, land on your enemies shore, and truck it to a safehouse in your target city. Let is sit there until you need to detonate it.
- evgen 6y agoGiven the amount of attention that has been paid to just this sort of scenario for more than two decades (along with prodigious spending on detection capability at ports) I would bet large sums that the answer to that is 0 or possibly 1. The danger of what you suggest is in getting caught, and the terribly unpleasant consequences of same; if I were in charge when some country tried that my first question would be if we knew where every family member of the leadership of that country slept...
- 6y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> and turn the area into a charred wasteland, unfarmable and uninhabitable for centuries to come. I believe the lad test understanding is that it would not be like this. Most likely, after a year, if you plowed under the topsoil, you could get back to farming.
- giantg2 6y agoI think it depends on the level of contamination and the isotopes. You could need to remove up to 18" top soil depending on a bunch of factors. Some places don't have that much, and the soil underneath is not suitable for farming.
- flyinglizard 6y agoI’d be excited to see 1.24 million elementary school teachers launched across the world to retaliate after a nuclear strike. It would be the crown jewel in a long streak of aeronautical achievements by the US establishment.
- wait_a_minute 6y agoThe simplest answer is - they are not building it for usage on earth. They are building it just in case we need it for these guys: https://www.cnet.com/news/harvard-astronomy-professor-avi-loeb-more-sure-than-ever-we-were-visited-by-alien-spacecraft/ https://www.cnet.com/news/harvard-astronomy-professor-avi-lo...
- jablongo 6y agoStupid question : Why not spend $100 Bn instead on fundamental fusion reactor research and put some testing facilities in rural Wyoming? I’m sure many could disagree w/ this on similar grounds (“why not spend on healthcare”), but the use of the money is similar enough and could employ some of the same locals that modernizing ICBMs would.
- sto_hristo 6y ago> The reasons for the GBSD are historical, political, and to a significant extent economic. There is nothing historical about communism and its desire to take over everything. Putin's origin is from pure communism, just like every other leader in any country that used to be in the Soviet block. Does the author really think that just because they changed clothes and names, they changed their identity? Lower the guard and a punch will follow. Cold War was not won and it's not over, it's merely extended under an unspoken armistice.
- erentz 6y agoAnyone finding themselves interested in this stuff should pick themselves up a copy of Daniel Ellsberg’s book The Doomsday Machine: Confessions of a Nuclear War Planner. He elaborates a lot of the history of our nuclear strategy and development of arsenals, and why land based missiles don’t make sense.
- nico42 6y ago600 more atomic bombs on this earth. You never know, if there is still a few cockroaches still alive after the 500th bomb you drop, you still have 100th more...
- simonblack 6y agoKeep spendin' dem trillions, boss.
- tim333 6y agoIt's always seemed to me that it might be an idea to reduce weapons of deterrence down to what is needed to do the job. What do we need to actually stop Russia or China launching a nuclear attack? Maybe 5 bombs that could take out Moscow, St Petersburg, Vladivostok and couple of bases would probably be adequate to put them off. Apart from the extra cost of a super dooper vapourise everything system, it increases the risks if a Dr Stangelove situation goes down.
- russellbeattie 6y agoThere's around 1.8 million elementary school teachers in the U.S. - I've never considered how much it costs to pay them every year. Wow.