15 ms·
Why Birds Don’t Get Cold Feet
- Retric 6y agoThis doesn’t explain why the interstitial fluids and cells themselves in a birds feet avoid freezing. Presumably, either their feet can simply be maintained at slightly above freezing or they use some form of antifreeze. Does anyone know?
- ericmay 6y agoI don’t know, but I’m always amazed at how animals don’t just all freeze to death and die. I know that many do but still.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoThey're always out there, so their bodies adapt. We're capable of it too, many of us just don't try because it is uncomfortable at first. I think it's worth doing, because the process of adapting also conditions our bodies to be stronger and more resilient in many ways. Cold conditioning has been proven to boost the immune system and many other health factors. https://www.wimhofmethod.com/cold-therapy https://www.wimhofmethod.com/cold-therapy
- Ekaros 6y agoEvolution? We are rather different from those species that have adapted to colder climates. But there really is quite many ways to combat it. Move underground or even under snow, eat enough. In general have sufficient metabolism and insulation.
- Causality1 6y agoExactly. I want to know what cellular metabolic tricks they use to keep their foot cells working at just over freezing temperatures.
- soheil 6y agoWhat about a simple anti-freezing agent used in something like a car radiator? This doesn't seem like it should be such a mystery in the age of Google and Wikipedia. There are bacteria and other multicellular organisms that function just fine in extreme cold environments. See extremophiles, psychrophiles, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 6y agoFreezing is not the only threat. The functioning of cells depends on proteins that only work effectively within certain temperature ranges. Ectotherms tend to have multiple different pathways for a given process that cover several different temperature ranges while endotherms don't. So, do birds have that? Do their feet still grow, heal, fight infections when they're cold or do they depend on time spent with their feet warm?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe article says this: It’s pretty much all tendons and bones. So, unlike your human foot, which contains plenty of moist muscle tissue, a bird’s foot contains only very little fluid in its cells.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoyes but the parent commenter seems to think this is not adequate to explain it.
- Retric 6y agoIt seems like they do keep their feet above freezing. Which is counter to the article’s: “Given a bird’s frantic little heart, blood simply rushes by way too fast to freeze.” As the blood never actually reaches freezing temperatures. “Warm blood moving toward the feet is cooled, which helps penguins keep their feet at temperatures just above freezing.” http://blogs.britannica.com/2011/01/penguin-feet-avoiding-frostbite-in-the-antarctic/ http://blogs.britannica.com/2011/01/penguin-feet-avoiding-fr...
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe only things I can readily find just reiterate what is in this article about heat exchange in the blood vessels: https://www.birdnote.org/listen/shows/why-birds-feet-dont-freeze https://www.birdnote.org/listen/shows/why-birds-feet-dont-fr... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_feet_and_legs#Thermal_regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_feet_and_legs#Thermal_reg... One article I briefly looked at indicates there isn't as much study of avian ...something ....as mammalian. Maybe fattiness because I was wondering if they have any adipose tissue in their feet. Oil is harder to freeze than water. I also googled for info about saltiness and bird feet, which helped me find some article about "antifreeze" in various species but it barely mentions birds in passing: https://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/19/science/19creatures.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/19/science/19creatures.html Salt gets used to de-ice roads in winter because it changes the freezing point of water. But I am not readily finding anything that indicates we have found a chemical antifreeze mechanism in bird feet. It may exist but not have been studied or looked for at all. Edit: Though upon closer examination, the article about animal "antifreeze" talks about proteins that serve that function, which is a new one on me. So someone else would need to google up info on protein structures of bird feet and speculate if those could have antifreeze properties. I don't know that much about protein and its impact on physiological characteristics (other than, you know, it's pertinent to insulin resistance or something, which most diabetics seem unfamiliar with while we blame everything on fat and overlook the role of lack of muscle).
- Daho0n 6y agoI'm not sure if I can trust a random article on the internet but I do (mostly) trust my eyes. I have lots of small bird-feet-tracks outside my window where they have melted the snow. So clearly either they are not freezing because they are warm or they are covered in anti-freeze.
- aembleton 6y agoOr the pressure on the feet puts marks into the snow.
- Sharlin 6y agoTheir feet are kept slightly above freezing by the very mechanism explained by the article. It's a heat exchanger, basically. Warm blood from the heart is used to keep cold blood in the extremities from freezing, and this "double loop" system is much more efficient than pushing warm blood directly into the feet where thermal losses would be much greater.
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI was sleeping on a balcony in Hawaii on a trip, when I woke up there was a one legged pigeon that was hanging out right next to me. Ever since then I noticed quite a few birds with a missing foot. Makes me wonder how much sensitivity birds have in their feet.
- serf 6y agoLooks can sometimes be deceiving with regards to one-legged birds. My pet goose (yeah, weird pet, but she was from an egg I saved and incubated) does a trick where when she sleeps she puts her head under under a wing and lifts a leg up -- she sleeps on a single leg with her head tucked like a big ball of balanced feathers with tremendous balance and grace. She tucks her leg up so high into her down fluff that you can't see it at all. She only wobbles a bit when she's deeply asleep -- never falling. Here is a picture of a different species of goose (I have a Toulouse) doing the same behavior[0]. It's not terribly uncommon among birds. Of course REAL one-legged birds exist, just wanted to mention that they like to confuse people once in awhile :) [0]: https://p0.pikist.com/photos/373/410/nature-wildlife-bird-goose-canada-goose-sleeping-profile-swamp-summer.jpg https://p0.pikist.com/photos/373/410/nature-wildlife-bird-go...
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI know the behaviour you are describing, but the pigeon had its foot severed at the ankle. I saw the actual leg, so its not that it was hiding it. Looked more like pirate stub.
- serf 6y agoAh , that's too bad. This article mentions a correlation between pollution and loss-of-limbs in urban pigeons. They even mention it may due to human hair entanglement from hair salons as a primary culprit -- that seems far fetched to me, but who knows.[0] I tend to think that it's mostly just environmental entanglement, pigeons are pretty curious animals. [0]: https://www.birdspot.co.uk/bird-brain/why-do-so-many-urban-pigeons-have-missing-legs-or-feet https://www.birdspot.co.uk/bird-brain/why-do-so-many-urban-p...
- pfdietz 6y agoCountercurrent exchange is a remarkable thing that every engineer should know about.
- umvi 6y agoCan you list some examples of where this is used in engineering (software or otherwise)?
- throwawayboise 6y agoA fresh air exchanger in an HVAC system. The fresh external air coming in is [warmed|cooled] by the interior air being exhausted.
- fy20 6y agoAlso know as a heat recovery ventilator. If you are building a new house, read up on these, as you probably want one.
- pfdietz 6y agoOpen hearth steel mills. Regenerators in some gas turbines. Dialysis machines. Liquid-liquid extraction. Isotope separation cascades. Fractional distillation columns. Most heat exchangers are countercurrent, as it minimizes entropy generation.
- Retric 6y agoMilk pasteurization is one of the best examples. You start with milk at 4C, heat it to ~70C via heat exchanger (+66C), then 75c via heating (+5C), wait 15 seconds for pasteurization, cool down to ~9C via heat exchanger (-66C), then just chill to 4C via refrigeration (-5C). This requires ~1/14th the energy to heat the milk and also rapidly cools it down below ambient temperature afterwards saving even more energy. You see similar approaches for a lot of large scale chemical processes.
- dorfsmay 6y ago
- forgotmypw17 6y agoThis is anecdata. I am also not a bird. Inspired by Wim Hof, I've started doing short barefoot snow walks. Within days, even between multiple walks on the same day, my feet became more cold-tolerant. They now recover from the cold faster, stay warm in the snow longer, and when I'm indoors, my feet are no longer cold without socks. My feet used to be cold to the touch and feel cold subjectively without socks.
- goblin89 6y agoInteresting. From my experience, coldness of feet is correlated with blood circulation. There are periods when my feet are cold (going together with the restless legs syndrome at night), and I think it goes away when circulation improves. My theory is that exposing feet to elements is another trick to improve blood flow to them, I’ve been meaning to try that.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoIf you don't have any snow to walk through, just give 'em an ice water dip. You can do your whole body, too, with similar benefits. It's uncomfortable, but what isn't... In my experience, and I've not found any studies to support this, restless legs correlates with oxygen levels vs carbon monoxide and/or carbon dioxide levels. Check your air.
- goblin89 6y agoMaybe oxygen then? Worse circulation or carbon monoxide could be involved, then. I don’t think there’s anywhere for CO to come from, however air quality varies (CO2 levels easily reach 1000 ppbv at times).
- forgotmypw17 6y agoYes, that's what I meant. I've edited my comment.
- trhway 6y ago
- safog 6y agoI feel like I’ve read articles about birds feet not getting cold from four different sources (Reddit, YT, Twitter and now HN) in the past week. Why is everyone suddenly so interested in birds?
- dgarrett 6y agoMust be a submarine PR campaign by Big Bird.
- tbyehl 6y agoIDK but I picked up one of my hen this morning and thought "Wow, her feet are COLD." Bird feet may not normally get frostbite or whatever, but they certainly do get cold.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoThat's a feature, not a bug. It prevents losing energy.
- Sharlin 6y agoBecause of… how the social media, and your social bubble, fundamentally works? An article that becomes popular on one site naturally spreads to other sites by people sharing it. Also, the Baader–Meinhof effect, which primes you to notice things you've learned about recently.
- pfdietz 6y agoWarm bloodedness (endothermy) would not be possible without countercurrent exchange in nasal passages. We have intricate bones there that capture heat and humidity in exhaled gas, then transfer it back to incoming air on the next breath. Without this the energy cost would be prohibitive. Structures like these in fossils are used as markers of the evolution of endothermy in ancestors of mammals and birds.
- alien_ 6y agoI'm not a biologist, but shouldn't this only matter in cold climate? If the climate is warm enough the animals actually would need to have ways to actively cool down, like through sweating. Would capturing heat from their expiration still be needed?
- simongr3dal 6y agoWouldn't the mechanism work wether it's warm or cold relative to body temperature? The relative warmness of the breath could be captured on the way out and heat up incoming air, or it could capture the relative coolness of the breath on the way out and cool down incoming air.
- nealdotpy 6y ago> If you’ve ever chewed on a chicken foot, What?
- aembleton 6y agoChicken feet are cooked and eaten in many countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_feet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_feet