3 ms·
In the UK, IR35 legislation (introduction delayed because of covid) would probably designated you as a 'disguised’ employee - ie contracting only to get the tax
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
In the UK, IR35 legislation (introduction delayed because of covid) would probably designated you as a 'disguised’ employee - ie contracting only to get the tax benefits of working via an intermediary company (less tax, paying yourself as dividends etc).
https://www.hiscox.co.uk/business-blog/what-is-ir35-and-what-does-it-mean-for-contractors-hiscox-uk https://www.hiscox.co.uk/business-blog/what-is-ir35-and-what...
- gpmcadam 6y agoExcept they would actually have none of the benefits and security of being an employee by choice, so that argument is total tosh if you ask me No holidays, no sick pay, no minimum notice term, no overtime, no bonus, no 20% time, no paid lunches or benefits.
- simias 6y agoDisguised employees are generally advantageous for the company, not the worker.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoFor low paid drivers yes, but I know a lot of high paid software developers who would say otherwise.
- simias 6y agoFor sure, but it's always higher risk/higher reward. If you're young and healthy you can probably earn more working that way, but if you're older, have a mortgage, have health issues, need maternity leave, have children in a nearby school and you don't want to move etc... The security and benefits of a salaried position can be worth more in the long run.
- zajio1am 6y agoDepends on country. Here in Czechia due to tax advantages for self-employed the net worker income may be more than 50% bigger for self-employed than for regular emplyees with the same level of company expenses.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoBut they would be being 'paid' perhaps double the employee rate. Paying yourself and spouse with dividends (20% tax) rather than a salary, taking lots of business expenses, and withholding income until needed. A few years ago this was common in many London investment banking dev jobs - it appealed to both the companies and certain developers. Often those who had other business interests. I had a colleague whose contracting company was paying his wife in gold via an offshore company to further reduce tax paid (I only remember that from a drunken discussion so can't swear to its truthfulness)
- Nursie 6y agoDangerous now, HMRC have the power to retroactively declare schemes like that illegal and go after back-taxes and penalties. The space used to be rife with those sorts of schemes, I used to get phone calls - "We found your CV on a recruitment site, we understand you're a contractor. How would you like to keep 95% of your gross earnings?" They seem to have died down a lot now.
- youngtaff 6y ago> But they would be being 'paid' perhaps double the employee rate. Paying yourself and spouse with dividends (20% tax) rather than a salary, taking lots of business expenses, and withholding income until needed. Dividends only save NI rather than tax as only first 2K is tax free, then its' 7.5% to the end of the lower rate band, and then something else in the higher one (andahdn as they come from profits corporation tax has already been paid on them) Real savings come from avoiding NI, and having partners as co-employees / directors / shareholders so the 'income' can be split between two people rather than one Offshore companies and gold bars is ripe for HMRC taking a closer look
- tchalla 6y agoIn Germany, there's a similar title denoted as "Scheinselbststaendigkeit" or a "Pseudo False Self-Employment". https://www.freelancermap.de/blog/aktuelle-rechtslage-zur-scheinselbststaendigkeit/#merkmale-scheinselbststaendigkeit https://www.freelancermap.de/blog/aktuelle-rechtslage-zur-sc...
- cameronh90 6y agoNothing I can see in his comment would exclude him from contracting outside of IR35. There's a questionnaire you can do here: https://www.tax.service.gov.uk/check-employment-status-for-tax/disclaimer https://www.tax.service.gov.uk/check-employment-status-for-t... It seems more likely to come down to setting your own hours, can you pay other people to do work for you, can you have other clients, are you using your own equipment, etc.
- fallingknife 6y ago> setting your own hours, can you pay other people to do work for you, can you have other clients, are you using your own equipment This sounds much more like what I would think the definition of contractor is, except for maybe you can subcontract the work. That would be something I would think could go either way in a contract.