4 ms·
This article is a very interesting example of capitalization on the Lump of labour fallacy. Two examples made it very obvious: 1. there's only one diagram, an
by pizza234 6y ago
This article is a very interesting example of capitalization on the Lump of labour fallacy.
Two examples made it very obvious:
1. there's only one diagram, and it looks catastrophic. the article is designed to give the reader the impression that there is a catastrophe going on, by hiding the counterpart (that is, jobs created in the meanwhile)
2. cleverly, what the article doesn't show, it describes, in ridiculous terms:
> from the point of view of, say, a 10th century farmer, over
> 90% of the jobs we do now are effectively made up–make-work
> stopgaps that simply prove, in the words of Mark Twain, that
> "civilization is a limitless multiplication of unnecessary
> necessaries."
so, 90% of the jobs that didn't exist in the 10th century are essentially... vanity.
- rakkhi 6y agoI thought the article was a good balanced perspective without providing a conclusion either way. Thus wanting to start the debate here :)