6 ms·
Ever been on an airplane? Altitude was almost certainly measured in kilofeet. As noted in other comments, NASA (like the rest of the United States [1]) does u
by mulmen 6y ago
Ever been on an airplane? Altitude was almost certainly measured in kilofeet.
As noted in other comments, NASA (like the rest of the United States [1]) does use the metric system.
But it doesn’t matter. Nothing about the metric system makes it uniquely suitable to landing on Mars. Or space travel in general. What matters is a consistent standard.
Internally NASA could use Armstrongs. Where 1 is the weight or height of Neil Armstrong at KSC on July 16, 1969 at 13:32:00 UTC. It doesn’t matter. As long as it is consistent.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_St...
- dieortin 6y agoIt does matter. See the errors caused in the past by using the imperial system. The metric system has a number of advantages.
- mulmen 6y agoThe errors were not caused by the imperial system. The errors were caused by using the imperial system and the metric system. Specifically in expecting one system and getting the other.
- bernulli 6y agoThe thing is, though, that you have these conversions even within the imperial system (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_units#/media/File%3AEnglish_Length_Units_Graph.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_units#/media/File%3...) but not within the metric system. My experience with U.S. students is that they are having a much harder time making sense of the imperial system (that they are used to) than doing problems in metric, even though they don’t use it in everyday life.
- mulmen 6y agoOk, so? First off, you linked to a list of english measures which are not used in the US. Nobody uses fathoms or barleycorns. Here is the list of actual US customary units: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_units https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_unit... Second, none of that is relevant to landing on Mars. The only problem space where metric has an advantage is in converting between meters, kilometers and millimeters. That’s great, and it’s easy to learn. But it doesn’t suddenly make all problems of distance easier to solve. If I am traveling toward Mars at 47 meters per second it doesn’t help me to know that is also .047km per second. And converting to kilometers per hour involves using base 60 twice anyway because metric time is unwieldy. In reality none of your measurements are going to be nice round numbers. Mentally converting from meters to km might be nice sometimes but it’s essentially a party trick. It won’t help the lander make decisions. The hardware doesn’t inherently work in base 10. Does NASA mix meters and kilometers? Isn’t that the same problem that destroyed the Mars Climate Orbiter? The fact is the units are irrelevant beyond just being defined and used consistently. Also, I can’t think of a situation where I need to convert miles to feet. My bike ride is six miles, I’m never going to express that in feet. If I need to describe the size of a thing in a room I will probably use feet, maybe inches if it is small. Probably not feet and inches. I wouldn’t use miles at all. Easy conversion between those units just isn’t a problem that comes up. It’s more important to me to have reasonably sized units and that the person I am communicating with understands them.
- lmm 6y ago> If I am traveling toward Mars at 47 meters per second it doesn’t help me to know that is also .047km per second. Yes it does. It means you can immediately sanity-check your numbers even if you don't have a good sense of what meters and kilometers are, because you have that base/kilo relationship. > My bike ride is six miles, I’m never going to express that in feet. You can eyeball how fast you're going in feet per second and have a rough idea of how long your ride is going to take. Or rather you could if you had any idea of how long your ride was in feet. There are lots of little everyday things that just become much easier.
- mulmen 6y ago
- zajio1am 6y ago>The errors were caused by using the imperial system and the metric system Using one universally accepted system is core idea behind metric system. Now, it looks like it is competition between two equal systems, but historically it is competition between ideas 'we should have one universal system' and 'every country/area can stay on their local systems'. Just all other legacy local systems (outside u.s. customary) disappeared.
- Melkman 6y agoConsistency is not the only value of a system of units. Convenience is also of importance. And that is where the metric system shines. Having all measures of a unit in multiples 10 combines perfectly with our decimal calculations. Having as few as possible magical numbers to convert and combine between units makes making mistakes harder. How many calories in kinetic energy has a pound going 10 miles per hour ? I know a kilo going 10 meters per second has 50 joules of kinetic energy without looking up anything and doing the calculation in my head.
- mulmen 6y agoIf working with simple units of ten is beneficial then every mission should redefine units in terms of expected velocities and vehicle size so they are optimized for the actual calculations at hand. That's not realistic, obviously, so we just pick one. The units in the system are arbitrary, really. In reality regardless of the system you choose every calculation is going to end up with fractions of something. You aren't just going to do it in your head.
- heisenzombie 6y agoPhysicists are quite fond of redefining units so that the constants they care about are all just 1. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_units). For example, you could define mars units where the gravitational acceleration on mars is 1. Now your velocity in freefall is just equal to the time you've been freefalling! You don't even have to do a calculation! (note: Don't actually do this. Gravitational acceleration isn't a constant when you're doing orbital mechanics.)
- mulmen 6y agoHonestly I would expect something like that to be happening at a hardware level. The number of bits in a memory address for the ground sensing radar is very interesting. Or the algorithm to determine vehicle acceleration given the voltage reading of a solid-state sensor vs the baseline. The metric system vs the imperial system is not an interesting distinction in these contexts.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoQuick, how many miles is 26357 feet? With metric it's a matter of shifting the decimal. How much is a sixteenth inch anyways.
- mulmen 6y agoYes, conversion between mm, cm, m and km is easy. What's your point? If something is miles away why do I care about it in terms of feet? How many meters is the sun from here? How many km is 1/3 of an AU? How many seconds does it take light to go a meter in vacuum? A 16th is half an 8th. Twice as much as a 32nd. AKA 2^4, 2^3 and 2^5, respectively.