3 ms·
I'll be honest and say I have no idea what those links are supposed to tell me.... The idea that a bill proposal article is somehow going to " rarely go anywhe
by duxup 6y ago
I'll be honest and say I have no idea what those links are supposed to tell me....
The idea that a bill proposal article is somehow going to " rarely go anywhere" and etc seems such a generic idea that you could apply to anything.
It's clear in this thread and others that content of the bill and the issues it involves is what drives the discussion, not the fact that it is just a bill proposal, and that's what should determine the quality or whatever we're determining about the discussion.
As for 'ideological' that again seems a simple way of just applying a generic stamp that could go on any topic.
These brush strokes you use are way too wide and random IMO.
Beyond that if ideology even does plays into things, that's not a reason to sweep it away. Ideology has collided with infectious disease, we still talk about it. If there's too much ideology in a thread, that just seems like a great tool for folks to use to simply derail the discussion.
- dang 6y agoThe links are supposed to tell you that this is standard, well-established moderation practice that has been explained countless times and has been going on for years. They're also supposed to save me from having to write an essay-length explanation every time, since I can't do that. Yes of course ideology and politics enter into lots of things. The question is if an article has enough substance to support an intellectually interesting discussion that doesn't end up being dominated by flamebait and boilerplate. There's no intention to sweep political or ideological topics away altogether. That's another point that's been explained many times, but I'm afraid I have to give you another one of those links to point to it: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=political%20overlap%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... These criteria don't seem particularly wide to me and they certainly aren't random. They've evolved out of the 13+ years of experience we've had running this place. I do get, though, that they can seem random at the level of a particular post, from the perspective of anyone who hasn't seen the dozens/hundreds/thousands of previous cases that motivate the moderation style. That's another reason why I quote those links so often - it's an attempt to show how the practices here have accrued from a large corpus of similar cases over a long time. The main thing we're trying to avoid on HN is too much repetition. The generic topic in this case has been repeated many times over many years on HN, and since there isn't a significant new development in this case (that's the point about bill proposals), there's nothing to steer the thread in a non-repetitive direction. To my eye the comments in this one make that point quite clearly.
- duxup 6y agoI can understand not wanting to write an essay every time. I've moderated forums myself. The reason I mentioned the links was because 'this is the policy' didn't really seem to apply when I was addressing the amorphous reasons for the policy that could apply to any number of active discussions on HN right now. I didn't doubt it was an actual policy. But either way it's not my call, best of luck to you.
- dang 6y ago> I can understand not wanting to write an essay every time Thanks for that. I can understand not wanting to read several whole bunches of old moderation comments :)