5 ms·
> lot of land that isn't suitable for farming We're talking about powering a hydroponic greenhouse. The alternative to "Solar Powered LEDs" isn't "plant things
by dragontamer 6y ago
> lot of land that isn't suitable for farming
We're talking about powering a hydroponic greenhouse. The alternative to "Solar Powered LEDs" isn't "plant things in the ground". Its "make a glass window on your roof".
--------
"Plant things in the ground" is also cheaper, though it does suffer from potentially poor soil conditions. Still, it seems to me that spreading fertilizer across soil (and conditioning the soil into a growable state) would be cheaper and easier than making large-scale indoor hydroponics.
- dathinab 6y ago> "make a glass window on your roof". Doesn't work as you can't stack plants with it nor can you grow them underground.
- dragontamer 6y agoWhere are you placing these solar panels? Why can't those locations be rooftop hydroponic farms instead?
- tux1968 6y agoBecause rooftop hydroponic farms have to be tended to almost daily, or at least for planting/harvesting. Solar panels don't need nearly as much maintenance and allow you to concentrate the actual growing operations for the economies of scale. Do you mind if I ask why you're so against the idea?
- dragontamer 6y ago> Do you mind if I ask why you're so against the idea? Because it is clearly inefficient to convert sunlight -> electricity -> simulated sunlight.
- tux1968 6y agoBut you're ignoring the inefficiency of building separate hydroponic operations on individual rooftops and driving around to all of them, etc. Also as SamBam mention above, you don't have to make a simulated sun. Instead it can work as sun -> electricity -> narrow-spectrum-light-that-plants-convert-at-higher-efficiency. You might even genetically modify plants to be more productive with the smallest spectrum possible.
- Ekaros 6y agoOr the obvious solution: put hydroponics on traditional close to ground greenhouses... Potentially best of both worlds, if they are sufficiently distributed on outskirts of cities.
- youngtaff 6y agoHydroponics is how many commercial growers operate their greenhouses
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hansvm 6y ago> lot of land that isn't suitable for farming > We're talking about powering a hydroponic greenhouse. The alternative to "Solar Powered LEDs" isn't "plant things in the ground". Its "make a glass window on your roof". I think what they were getting at is that you can take land wholly unsuitable for farming or greenhouses (e.g. severe slopes), apply solar panels, and then funnel that energy to a vertical farm. Since the vertical farm does save space in the abstract (just not necessarily once accounting for space needed for electricity generation), the scheme overall is still a more efficient use of land.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Since the vertical farm does save space in the abstract (just not necessarily once accounting for space needed for electricity generation) I severely doubt that. Solar panels are maybe 30% efficient. So 10-acres of glass-roofs need to be replaced by 30-acres of solar panels just to account for this inefficiency (let alone other inefficiencies: such as wiring, inverter, batteries, and LEDs). Maybe 50-acres of solar panels to be anywhere close to comparable against 10-acres of glass roofs once we include other inefficiencies.
- SamBam 6y ago> Solar panels are maybe 30% efficient. So 10-acres of glass-roofs need to be replaced by 30-acres of solar panels Not remotely. Plants are also extremely inefficient, converting only about 1% of the solar energy that falls for their use. [1] Most of this inefficiency is from solar energy being in the form of frequencies that the plants can't use, but solar panels can. So the panels can capture this energy, then funnel into the red and orange lights that are most efficient for plant growth. I've read a bunch on this, and haven't been able to find an authoritative source for what the efficiency conversion is -- how many acres of solar panels power how many acres of vegetables, and is it greater or less than 1:1? -- but it's certainly not as simplistic as "solar would need 3x more land because they are 30% efficient." 1. https://phys.org/news/2012-01-energy-conversion-solar-cells.html https://phys.org/news/2012-01-energy-conversion-solar-cells....
- 6y ago
- msla 6y ago> "Plant things in the ground" is also cheaper, though it does suffer from potentially poor soil conditions. "Poor soil conditions" to include "soil" that is alkali dust, sand, dry for eleven months out of the year, frozen solid and under multiple feet of snow for more than half the year, and so far from either a river or reliable groundwater that any and all water used must be trucked in. In tanks. On trucks. Plus, you only get to dump more fertilizer in the water if you filter it back out again.
- e_y_ 6y agoOr maybe something like what's being investigated for greenhouses on Mars (which gets less than half the sunlight that Earth receives) using mirrors and optical fiber cables to redirect light.
- dicroce 6y agoYes! I wonder if there is a way to make a light battery? :)
- e_y_ 6y agoLight has a tendency to zoom off at, well, the speed of light, and colliding with objects causes it to lose energy. There have been some experiments in slowing down or "stopping" light although they involve some elaborate setups that almost certainly use more energy to trap the light than you'd get from storing it. You could also store it in or orbiting in a black hole, but good luck getting it back in its original form! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_sphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_sphere