4 ms·
There were documented procedures: > The Fund Sighting Manual explains that, in order to suppress payment of a principal amount, “ALL of the below field[s] must
by jkaptur 6y ago
There were documented procedures:
> The Fund Sighting Manual explains that, in order to suppress payment of a principal amount, “ALL of the below field[s] must be set to the wash account: FRONT[;] FUND[; and] PRINCIPAL”
and checklists:
> Raj then emailed Fratta, seeking final approval under the six-eye review process, explaining “NOTE: Principal set to Wash and Interest Notice released to Investors.”
and confirmations:
> which prompted a warning on his computer screen — referred to as a “stop sign” — stating: “Account used is Wire Account and Funds will be sent out of the bank. Do you want to continue?” But “The ‘stop sign’ did not indicate the amount that would be ‘sent out of the bank,’
To answer your question "Why were these 3 employees left to assume they were using the tool correctly, rather than referring to a definitive documented procedure that would give them the answer for sure?" My guess is that the manual is a million pages long and incredibly confusing.
My takeaway from this is that you can't train and document your way out of a core human factors issue. Your point about SQL queries is apt; that's why you don't just give humans access to prod.
- dmix 6y agoThat's a good point, besides not following the documentation (or they weren't aware they were supposed to "suppress payment of principal amount). They UI "stop sign" prompt should show the # of on the confirmation machine. It should accurately summarize everything they are doing, not just a simple "yes/no" they've seen a bunch of times. Just like in Hawaii when they sent the wrong cell phone warning of an incoming NK missile attack, it could easily have been prevented if there was a dialog which said "You're sending this 'prompt' as a live alert to millions of cellphones (yes/no)". Software always assumes people are paying attention but for serious usecases like this (which can't be undone for example, or sending hundreds of millions) there should be a sanity check dialog with real information.