3 ms·
When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask them to do a day of "trial surgeries". They just assume they have the necessary skills. The reason they can
by jedberg 6y ago
When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask them to do a day of "trial surgeries". They just assume they have the necessary skills.
The reason they can do that is because there are national standards for graduating which includes a board exam to test academic knowledge as well as a multi-year paid internship.
There are pros and cons to this type of system. Pros include knowing that anyone with a degree is qualified and maintaining minimum standards.
The cons is that is very much limits supply of doctors and locks out a lot of otherwise qualified people who can't get into a program, often excluding poor and minority folks.
But maybe there is a hybrid? Maybe we as an industry can come up with a test that anyone can study for and take and once you pass it you don't get trivia coding exams anymore. We just assume that you know what you're doing. Like a certification that everyone accepts.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat’s not necessarily true. Plenty of doctors are idiots whom you wouldn’t want to hire. Nobody just looks at your papers and hands out a white coat. Most of the interview hazing stuff happens because many applicants can’t handle a fizz-buzz question. Engineers/programmers being who they are like to optimize for whatever nonsense they care about. That devolves into this hunger games nonsense. You’ll see the culture change as tech becomes more diverse. Many of these quizzes end up becoming ways to objectify bias.
- jedberg 6y ago> Nobody just looks at your papers and hands out a white coat. But that is my point. You show up with your white coat that you earned by passing a series of tests. The future employer is just deciding if your stated skillset and your personality fit what they need. They aren't testing your skills as a doctor, because someone else already did.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Plenty of doctors are idiots whom you wouldn’t want to hire. Sure, but someone else has already given them the medical equivalent of fizzbuzz and other stupid generic whiteboarding challenges, so you can skip that for more specific tests of whether they are an idiot that you wouldn't want in the particular job.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "When a doctor interviews for a job, they don't ask them to do a day of "trial surgeries". They just assume they have the necessary skills." They have a grueling residency period that lasts three to seven years to make damned sure that they do. Can't imagine that anybody in the software industry is going to want to sign up for that.