7 ms·
1. ToS violation to record and publish shows without 'written' consent of all the people in the room (which is effectively not enforceable) 2. iOS only 3. Inv
by latchkey 6y ago
1. ToS violation to record and publish shows without 'written' consent of all the people in the room (which is effectively not enforceable)
2. iOS only
3. Invite only
4. Not ADA compliant (leaves out deaf folks)
5. Buggy
6. Centralized
7. You can't easily delete your account
8. Pushes hard to ingest your contacts, expanding their social graph
I personally tried it and deleted it. No thanks.
- hammock 6y ago>Pushes hard to ingest your contacts, expanding their social graph This is the #1 thing that new apps seem to do. Is it just a growth hack, or is there something nefarious about it? For example, I find it mindblowingly irritating that Telegram, of all things, blasts a notification announcing you've joined, the instant you join, to every other Telegram user who has your number saved in their phone. You can't opt out of this. And that's without even allowing access to your own contacts!
- pjc50 6y ago> Is it just a growth hack, or is there something nefarious about it? Yes. It's a nefarious growth hack.
- nlitened 6y agoAre we really gonna complain that audio-only app leaves out deaf folks? Come on!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 6y agoI think we have to consider whether the audio is the defining feature. Clearly with Spotify, it is, and an expectation that it works for deaf users would be ridiculous. I think with Clubhouse it's not. The defining feature is the network and social interaction, the audio is the format in the same way that on Facebook it's text. We expect Facebook to support screen readers for their text posts, so I think it's reasonable to expect that Clubhouse do something for deaf users. Whether they should be required to do this at an early stage or not is a different question in my opinion, but I think it's fair to consider eventual support the Right Thing To Do.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoproviding real time translations (and transcripts) is something skype has solved years ago. instead of reinventing conference-calls it wouldn't have hurt to at least provide one feature that justifies the data harvesting to the user.
- latchkey 6y agoI feel that your comment is insensitive. For context, this was posted in the Badger DAO discord by a deaf user: "I would like to recommend that we stop using Clubhouse. It has already been identified as one of the most inaccessibility platforms for individuals with disabilities. I am Deaf and I cannot access it - if it is going to continue to be used, it should have a transcript and coin giveaways should not happen unless it is on a platform that allows accessibility for all individuals with disabilities. It is a matter of time before Clubhouse catches up with accessibility but right now it is pretty much a fast moving platform because they aren't following accessibility requirements. This usually happens to new emerging companies and they move fast because they avoid accessibility. I hope @Spadaboom | BadgerDAO and @DeFiFry will give this some serious consideration and move to another platform that allows accessibility.- @Gabrielhaines is pretty good at this and could give some ideas for clubhouse alternatives."
- DLay 6y agoClubhouse will soon have major competition with Twitter Spaces too. It already has closed captioning, tweet based Q&A highlighting, and is integrated with Fleets. Looks to be the most meaningful update in a very long time for them.
- solosoyokaze 6y agoI think all of these products will quickly find that there is no mass-market demand for an audio only social network. This is a tool for self indulgence among "thought leaders" not something people actually want. Even podcasts, which I'd argue are more accessible than live rambling, are not a mass market product after more than a decade of trying.
- jimkleiber 6y agoRadio was one of the most mass market products, wasn't it? Not trying to be mean with that but to say that audio-only can be big as well. Maybe talk radio declined precipitously with video on TV yet I think there's still quite a huge market for listening to people talk and/or joining the conversation.
- solosoyokaze 6y agoI think that's the theory behind why people keep chasing this market, but radio's success was likely due to lack of competition. People have been banging on this door since Odeo.
- jimkleiber 6y agoWhat I've seen is that the barrier to join CH as a speaker is lower than being on video or maybe even writing in text. Audio only is much easier to produce, especially when one doesn't have to edit it, than video I'd say by orders of magnitude. Also, for people who don't like to read and write so much, speaking can be much easier. Will audio-only eat up video and text platforms? No. Video can provide much more rich info and text can be much quicker to read and in loud places. But I do think there is a spot for live audio-only content, just don't know how big it is and how that changes when the pandemic subsides.