5 ms·
Does Citibank have a case against Oracle? OSS licenses all have that "this software is not fit for any purpose at all, don't even think about suing us if it goe
by kibwen 6y ago
Does Citibank have a case against Oracle? OSS licenses all have that "this software is not fit for any purpose at all, don't even think about suing us if it goes wrong" clause, which would seem to imply that licensing poorly-made software can be grounds for a lawsuit.
- peeters 6y ago> which would seem to imply that poorly-made software can be grounds for a lawsuit. That doesn't necessarily follow, lawyers have a long tradition of including "cover your ass" clauses even if they don't think it's likely that they would be liable without it.
- lostcolony 6y agoIt could just as easily imply that OSS looked at commercial software and said "holy crap that's a lot of legalese; we better have some of that to make sure we don't get sued, since we don't even get to decide who uses what we put out there"
- tedunangst 6y agoSounds like the software does exactly what the (absurd) specification calls for. Somebody at Citi asked for a "front" knob, and they got one.
- PeterisP 6y agoHa - whatever OSS licences say, when you're dealing with terms written by Oracle lawyers, you're getting even less chances of successfully suing them if it goes wrong. You can argue about their technology, but the legal part of Oracle is quite capable, so much that I would assert that Citibank does not have a case against Oracle no matter what the software did. Pretty much all commercial software contracts includes similar idemnification clauses - they can't include the "not fit for any purpose" but the "if it goes wrong, it's not our problem" part definitely is there; and if it turns out to be not fit for purpose (which is ridiculously unlikely to prove for any actual product that's not totally made-up-nonexistent-fraudulent thing) then you might get back some of what you paid for it, but not for the losses you had due to it failing, assuming the licence/contract wasn't written by incompetent idiots.