3 ms·
Interesting. I'm not entirely sure how well the argument holds, but it does put forward some interesting points. One of the weaker aspects of this article is t
by swombat 18y ago
Interesting. I'm not entirely sure how well the argument holds, but it does put forward some interesting points.
One of the weaker aspects of this article is that the author doesn't define "value". I'll take a stab at it: for a business, the value of its software is how much money it can make or save from it. There are two components to this value, an immediate, obvious one ("can we sell/use it tomorrow?") and a long term, less obvious one ("can we still sell/use it in two year's time?").
The graphs and explanations, I think, apply fairly well to the "immediate value", but less so to the long-term value. The long-term value of code you can keep evolving, cheaply, to meet user demands for years, is much greater than that of ugly code that will become a viscous nightmare within a few months. Immediate value is very important too, but generally is focused on at the expense of long-term value, particularly by non-developers, who aren't fully aware that code can reach a point where it's so nasty that the only solution is a bullet to the head and a rewrite.
So I think the problem is more one of making the long-term value of beautiful code clearer, rather than one of flattening spikes. The curve to the right of the spike rises much faster and much higher than in the graphs, and it's worth moving there if you have people who are capable of it.
- pbh101 18y agoI think the graphs, bu fault of 'value' not being defined, are showing a hybrid of the long-term and immediate value of the code. Take, for example, a strict refactoring of the code, in the sense that only implementation is being changed and no features are being added. The immediate business value of that action is near zero, but the long term value is more. What the graphs point out is that, due to manual testing and production environments rigorously stress-testing a particular, perhaps brittle, snapshot of the code, the amount of refactoring and beautification of the codebase required to provide a baseline level of long-term value equivalent to the spike is much higher. Yes, the code will be cleaner, and easier to maintain and update for the future, and the resulting spikes from testing and production deployment will be that much higher, too. Take a look at the very last graph. I would posit that once the code is beautified and a more flexible version deployed, non-source readers would see another spike at the end, but from the original spike, it's hard to justify the valley of little incremental value.
- Tamerlin 18y agoYou're both missing something important. It's who decides on how to define "value" and in most cases, it's management, and it's almost invariably short-term value that wins out. The reason? Most organizations believe that software engineering is easy, and therefore software engineers are as interchangable as cogs. Most corporations don't understand or value experience.
- swombat 18y agoI'm not missing that. That's the gist of my comment...