4 ms·
From the article. "Bitcoin is deeply colonial, deeply extractive, and deeply damaging to the environment and marginalized people around the world. This privile
by inglor_cz 6y ago
From the article.
"Bitcoin is deeply colonial, deeply extractive, and deeply damaging to the environment and marginalized people around the world. This privileged crypto-colonialism almost exclusively benefits white men"
While just a few paragraphs before that, the author states that most Bitcoin mining is now happening in China...
I hate this neo-racist narrative so much, it sucks out oxygen and reason from every space it occupies. Is nowadays ecology subsumed under critical race theory? Can't you make an environmental argument without dumping on someone's skin color?
At least the author does not try to argue that Bitcoin is intrinsically transphobic, I would frankly expect it to be added to the mix above.
- risyachka 6y agoIt looks like the only reason for mentioning white men in the context of bitcoin is for the article to get some extra attention.
- zpeti 6y agoJust to be completely cynical about it, I think the author's aim is to get as much coverage and clicks as possible, and so is including every buzzword possible. Which of course in the current media climate means everything that you don't like is colonial and white supremacy.
- yoavm 6y agoI know nothing about who benefits from Bitcoin or where is it being mined, but isn't it plausible that group A is benefiting from asset X, while group B is mining it? If I'm not mistaken, that was the case with mining since pretty much forever...
- inglor_cz 6y agoOh, yes, but in this case, probably for the first time in history, group B (miners) consists of computers, not people. Owners of said computers are part of group A, and they are unlikely to sell freshly mined Bitcoin under market value. It is probably impossible to map ethno-religious structure of Bitcoin trade exactly, given that it often serves to circumvent regulations and thus necessarily partly lives in the shadows. But a lot of Bitcoin-related activity happens in East Asia, so the participants aren't probably majority white.
- caf 6y agoThe economics of the situation seem to point towards the owners of the mining operations making a fairly slim margin. The amount of electricity required to mine must rise until the mining input costs are close to the current Bitcoin price, because for as long as there are outsized returns from mining Bitcoin, more mining businesses will get into it and cause the difficulty to rise.
- inglor_cz 6y agoYes, but their margin is kinda-sorta certain, while speculants who buy the product run risk of sudden price collapse. No one will bail out Bitcoin speculants if it happens, they are no government's buddies. In other words, it is another globalized and pretty efficient market, but without outright slavery or serfdom on the chain beginning. Compared to guano mines or Potosi mines or even today's cobalt mines in Congo, the first humans in the chain are not miserable.
- yoavm 6y agoThat might be true, but the statement from the article still stands. Those who mine bitcoins (using their computers) are probably not those getting rich of it.
- caf 6y agoAre not those mining the coal that's burnt for the electricity to power the Bitcoin mining operations the first humans in the chain?
- simonh 6y agoIn the latest industrial disaster, 6 Chinese Bitcoin miners were trapped by a cave-in when their data centre collapsed on top of them. What do you imagine bitcoin mining is like? It seems a bit weird to compare it to actual underground mining.
- caf 6y agoIf it's true that Bitcoin mining is concentrated in these regions with cheap coal-fired electricity, there does seem to be a fairly direct linkage from coal-mining to coal-fired power plants to Bitcoin miners without too much of a reach. If Bitcoin mining is using 0.5% of the world's electricity output (a frankly astonishing number) and mining is concentrated in Xinjiang, then what percentage of Xinjiang's electricity usage is going to mining?
- yoavm 6y agoI never said mining Bitcoins was dangerous. Only that it makes a lot of sense that Bitcoin miners are usually not those who get rich from Bitcoin.
- robjan 6y agoThe people down in the mines digging gold / blood diamonds are replaced by computers. I don't think the people who own these computers are being exploited.
- yoavm 6y agoI don't know how people read anymore. I just mentioned that saying "This privileged crypto-colonialism almost exclusively benefits white men" does not contradict with saying Bitcoin is mined in China, like the parent comment was hinting.
- savolai 6y agoDoes the fact that the mining is happening in China somehow conflict with Elon Musk and western investors reaping the benefits? That’s what I understood the stated fact as. This is a genuine question, I’d like to understand the argument you’re making, vis-a-vis what the balance of who is benefiting and how much is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TheCapeGreek 6y agoMiners aren't mining for kicks and giggles.
- inglor_cz 6y agoTry invoking the "Jewish test". Imagine that the author dedicated a whole paragraph to the thought that Jews reap disproportional benefits from Bitcoin mining and that it is consistent with their long-term pattern of cartelizing, scheming and plotting to dominate the world economy on the backs of goyim. He would certainly come with some names, too, because the techno-nerd crowd in America has a sizeable Jewish component. But it would still scream to heaven. And this take is not much better, this kind of demonization of ethnicity is plain evil.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoIdentity politics is the new fad, it's getting out of hand frankly. Just throw it into anything when you don't have substance to present.
- panarky 6y agoA childhood friend has become very angry about tax exemptions for religious organizations. Curiously, he's not at all bothered by tax exemptions for the NFL, the NRA or other organizations. It's pretty obvious that he's not actually angry about the tax exemptions, it's the religious organizations he doesn't like. Similarly, there are many stories on HN by people who are very angry about the energy usage of Bitcoin. Curiously, they're not at all bothered by far greater wastes of energy from other technologies and industries. It's pretty obvious they're not actually angry about the energy use, it's Bitcoin they don't like.