5 ms·
It's kind of crazy that power plants are competing with consumers over a shared energy source: natural gas. You can use it to heat your home, or you can send i
by legitster 6y ago
It's kind of crazy that power plants are competing with consumers over a shared energy source: natural gas.
You can use it to heat your home, or you can send it to a power plant to convert it into electricity and heat your home at a 3x markup.
But regardless, you are relying heavily on a single resource in a single state.
- sp332 6y agoIn Texas' usual weather, an electric heat pump would be much more efficient than burning the gas for heat directly.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoPrescient post from November 2019 about transitioning Texas to heat pumps and the benefits of doing so. https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/a-texas-sized-gas-for-electricity-swap https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/a-texas-sized-g... > According to a paper from Pecan Street, an Austin-based energy research organization, the transition would reduce climate-warming pollution, save Texas households up to $452 annually on their utility bills, and flip the state from a summer-peaking to a winter-peaking system. And that winter peak would be “nothing the grid couldn’t evolve to handle,” according to co-author Joshua Rhodes.
- jounker 6y agoNot terribly prescient. The current cold snap has even shut down coal and nuclear plants in Texas.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoI'm discouraged no one is asking about the elephant in the room - which is why the polar vortex has shifted to the extent that these events are happening at all. It's not just Texas. There has been extreme cold across Europe, and unseasonable warmth across parts of the Arctic. Of course it's far too late to fix the primary cause now. But it's still true that extreme weather events caused by climatic instability were being discussed more than twenty years ago. Adding more of Power Source [X] is a bandaid. The real problem is structural, and it could have been solved more cheaply back then.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 6y agoPeople with heat pumps would all be running them as resistance heaters in the weather they are having right now. In that mode less of the energy in the gas becomes heat in the home (good furnaces are really good).
- toomuchtodo 6y agoQuality heat pumps will extract heat from the air even below 0F, and they are more efficient than resistive heat (disclaimer: I have a high quality heat pump). It's not a silver bullet, but combined with weatherizing homes properly, it would've reduced peak demand on ERCOT (although ERCOT should probably have pressure applied on it to force natural gas generation and infrastructure to winterize so that this infrastructure can continue to operate during extended cold snaps, because it's clear in the decade(s) ERCOT has known this is an issue [1], they haven't done a damn thing to address the problem). [1] https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/energy/article/Texas-grid-again-faces-scrutiny-over-cold-15955392.php https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/energy/article/Tex... ("A federal report that summer recommended steps including installing heating elements around pipes and increasing the amount of reserve power available before storms, noting many of those same warnings were issued after similar blackouts 22 years earlier and had gone unheeded.")
- maxerickson 6y agoIt's pretty predictable that people in (relatively warm) Texas would buy cheaper models that cut out at higher temperatures. Weatherization makes any heating and cooling more efficient too, so everyone should assess for improvements.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI'm just advocating for (or, attempting to) improved policy and planning around energy consumption and infrastructure. Penny wise pound foolish is getting old.
- throw0101a 6y agoMitsubishi units can still extract energy down to -13F / -25C: * https://www.mitsubishicomfort.com/benefits/hyper-heating https://www.mitsubishicomfort.com/benefits/hyper-heating These are designed in Japan, where they often have earthquakes, and so any flammable materials (natural gas) seem not to be used for heating. Things can get quite chilly up north: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rikubetsu,_Hokkaido https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rikubetsu,_Hokkaido * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hokkaidō#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hokkaidō#Climate AFAICT, the units do not have external thermometers, but rather look at the refrigerant temperature. So if the piping from the unit into your wall is short, then the refrigerant isn't exposed to the cold that much, and so may not effected as much by air temperature.
- throwawaysea 6y agoAn electric heat pump would not be cheaper than natural gas at heating. If you follow the rabbit hole of links from what you linked to, it comes to https://www.ideasmiths.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/IdeaSmiths-Final-Report-2019.pdf https://www.ideasmiths.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/IdeaSm... and the claim there is that summer cooling would be cheaper with newer more efficient heat pumps, and result in the annual heating/cooling expense being lower. But it’s not drawing a direct comparison of the cost of natural gas heat versus electric heat pump heat.
- toomuchtodo 6y agohttps://www.aceee.org/sites/default/files/publications/researchreports/a1602.pdf https://www.aceee.org/sites/default/files/publications/resea... > Our analysis finds that electric heat pumps generally use less energy in warm states and have moderately positive economics in these states if a heat pump can replace both the furnace and a central air conditioner. > Based on our analysis, we find that electric heat pumps have higher equipment and installation costs than gas furnaces and that electricity is generally more expensive per Btu than natural gas. As a result, in all of the comparisons the gas furnace has a lower life cycle cost for homes without central air-conditioning. However, if a central air conditioner can be replaced with a heat pump, the high-efficiency heat pump has lower life cycle costs in climates from Virginia southward as well as in the Northwest. This is shown by an analysis that credits the avoided cost of a central air conditioner and also includes cooling-energy savings from replacing a central air conditioner meeting federal minimum efficiency standards—a seasonal energy efficiency ratio (SEER) of 13 in the North and a SEER of 14 in the South—with a higher-efficiency heat pump > As discussed above, our analysis is only for existing homes. The results may be more positive toward heat pumps for new homes, as most new homes have air-conditioning and the cost of supplying gas to the home can be avoided by installing heat pumps. Note that this is a few years old (2016), and more efficient heat pumps improve the economics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe trick is that a natural gas furnace needs a decent chunk of electricity to operate, and we’re not very good at shedding all non-critical residential load. So it’s really not an either-or proposition for as long as we use natural gas for power, it’s a both-or-none situation.
- throwawaysea 6y agoThe majority of the energy use in a natural gas furnace is still the core heating of air functionality. The electric ignition and fan aren’t most of the energy to my knowledge, although “decent chunk” is a fuzzy term.
- lukeschlather 6y agoI have an oil furnace, and when I was looking into it it sounded like setting up a battery backup that could allow me to keep the fans running through a power outage like this would probably be more expensive than replacing the oil furnace with an electric one.
- rootusrootus 6y agoIf you have to use a battery, then that's probably true. But then again, once you have an electric furnace, the battery requirements are going to go up far more dramatically. As an anecdote, my furnace blower pulls about 11 amps on 120V AC. So I can run it with a little 2000W inverter generator but won't have much spare capacity for anything else.
- ashtonkem 6y agoObviously the blower and controller don’t consume anywhere near the amount of energy that gas delivers, but it consumes more than most people think. The blower on a typical furnace consumes 75-400W per hour of operation, depending on whether or not it’s a single speed or variable speed type. 400 watts per hour isn’t a huge amount of power, a space heater consumes about 1,300 watts per hour, but it’s still a pretty decent chunk of electricity. A deep discharge marine battery (common for cheap backup power) could keep a larger blower running for maybe 3 hours tops, assuming an unreasonable 100% discharge and 100% conversion efficiency. So, not a lot, but still something that you’d need some pretty specialized backup gear to run.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoWhich seems crazy to me. How is it cheaper and/or more efficient to create an entirely new system of gas pipes to every home so consumers can each inefficiently burn gas than simply converting the gas to electricity in a highly-efficient centralized plant and send the energy over the existing electrical infrastructure?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 6y agoYou’ve got it backwards on the efficiency front. Burning gas for heat at home beats out most forms of electric heat efficiency wise. A basic gas furnace is 80% efficient, with a nicer condensing unit being 96-98% efficient. Meanwhile most gas turbines hang out in the 32-38% efficiency range, plus transmission losses. Maybe if you’re using a heat pump and your local power plant is a triple pressure high efficiency model (~60% efficient) you might end up ahead, but for most users in most municipalities it’s actually better to burn the gas at home directly rather than at a power plant, at least for heat.
- pfdietz 6y agoAnd one can imagine home cogeneration that would produce power at the same time it heated the home.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoWow, I had no idea gas power plants were that inefficient. And I suppose it's a lot harder to turn natural gas into heat to produce electricity with turbines at a power plant, which is then sent to homes to turn back into heat with resistive heaters than it is to just send the natural gas straight to the homes in the first place. I didn't consider that those extra steps would add up to such a high loss.
- lawkwok 6y agoI recently submitted an article, which after I read it, made me think the same thing. We could’ve had cleaner indoor air and fewer points of failure if just used electricity. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26128180 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26128180