3 ms·
I'm going to say what you're carefully tip-toeing around. It isn't strange. It's normal. When you watch people's actions and not their words, you see what they
by renewiltord 6y ago
I'm going to say what you're carefully tip-toeing around. It isn't strange. It's normal. When you watch people's actions and not their words, you see what they truly believe. The Trolley Problem is most definitely solved in real life.
For instance, we can see that we allow rescue divers to die so that trapped children may be saved. The trolley problem has been solved: some number of cave divers' lives are worth less than some larger number of trapped childrens' lives.
Should we risk soldiers' lives going to Afghanistan so we can stop Osama Bin Laden and discourage hypothetical future violence against us? Yes, of course. Trolley problem solved.
Try it again with COVID-19 and you learn something. The truth is that we don't really care all that much about some elderly dying (rightly so). We care so little about their lives that we wouldn't even risk a thousandth as many people to save them. That's how it goes.
Revealed Preferences tell us all we need to know. There is a dollar sum for a life. Some lives are more valuable than other lives. And there is a banal variant of utilitarianism that flows through us all.
We are not fools. No species that risks nothing gains anything.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think your point is accurate, but more nuanced. you have to include accountability (e.g. blowback against the person who pulls the lever) Inaction is the most attractive option because the decision maker is can avoid blame. We could have taken an aggressive stance against covid, done challenge trials, mobilized manufacturing, used more controversal restrictions on movement. OR We could have taken a more laze fair approach, letting the elderly lock themselves down and die in greater numbers. Instead, we got some middling third option where politicians try to minimize accountability, and we get both very high deaths and very high economic disruption