4 ms·
It is unfortunate that journalists of 2021 see an accountability issue with individuals who can speak privately - but devote zero characters to Gov officials wh
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
It is unfortunate that journalists of 2021 see an accountability issue with individuals who can speak privately - but devote zero characters to Gov officials who use private email to dodge accountability via FOIA.
- minikites 6y agoWhich officials are those?
- nickff 6y agoMany government officials just avoid using e-mail at all for sensitive subjects, thus side-stepping the issue entirely. I remember Janet Napoletano (Secretary of Homeland Security) saying that she did most of her business over the phone or in-person to avoid having it on record.
- munk-a 6y agoWe have a real issue with partisan politics in the US and one of the pieces of fallout is that making a statement like that doesn't end your career. Laws on the public record exist to serve the general good and skirting them is indicative of taking actions you know will be met with general criticism and can't be justified.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Laws on the public record exist to serve the general good and skirting them is indicative of taking actions you know will be met with general criticism and can't be justified. Well, the counterargument is that it's indicative of taking actions that you know will be met with general criticism and can be justified.
- munk-a 6y agoHrm - I'll have a go at being less vague. By actions met by general criticism and can't be justified I meant actions that would both be met with criticism and, given enough surrounding information, wouldn't remove the majority of criticism. National security positions will need to execute actions that are pretty opaque and distasteful to the general public but, with that additional information in hand, would be reasonable to most people. So arresting some fellow who looks like a family man but was actually organizing an attack would be generally criticized but justifiable - on the other hand most forms of torture tend to be ineffective at information gathering and cause excessive pain and suffering and are less justifiable. For politicians I'm going to guess that a lot of stuff they don't want on record is specifically related to their self-betterment by somehow (even minorly) compromising their duty.
- amalcon 6y agoTo be fair, we also have an epidemic of partial statements being taken out of context and used against their speaker. Often, when contextualized, the quote most likely means the opposite of what it's being used to claim. I can easily think of examples of this being done to politicians of both major US political parties, and a handful of foreign politicians as well. A policy of staying off-record by default is not an unreasonable countermeasure to that problem.
- grawprog 6y agoWell when the same people that own media companies are lobbying and bribing politicians to receive throwbacks, seems pretty logical they'd view people speaking about this freely and privately as a problem. The media doesn't work for us. It works for its shareholders and most media shareholders are pretty alright with corruption in government because they're part of it.
- loceng 6y agoIt's why I am such a fan of Andrew Yang's core policy proposals including his "Journalism Dollars" - which I don't think he coined as such, but has a similar purpose to his Democracy Dollars: $100 every year for every citizen to allocate to a journalist of their choice. This would wash out the money received from advertising by the mainstream media channels, and so the narratives that are bought directly or indirectly and lifted up into mainstream via those ad dollars being spent/received - would open up to many more narratives with much more nuance to them, and stories that citizens actually care about; it's important for Journalism Dollars to exist with Ranked Choice Voting and Democracy Dollars as well - so it's not just the 2 core narratives of the duopoly of the two party system being perpetuated/promoted.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoAll these dollars would go to a journalist who promises to give $50 back.
- loceng 6y agoEasy problem to solve. You can implement mechanisms for integrity, e.g. whistleblower rewards for such behaviour.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoNot an easy problem to solve.
- glerk 6y agoMost of the work done by some "journalists" in 2021 is regurgitating what they see on social media. They wouldn't want to be deprived of this low hanging fruit and go back to doing hard investigative work.
- hddu 6y agoIt's insulting to real journalists to call the people at media corporations that just browse social media all day and copy stories as "journalists." They are just part of a content mill creating medium that can be attached to advertisments.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Most of the work done by some "journalists" in 2021 is regurgitating what they see on social media. There is a sharp schism between subscription journalism and ad-supported content. For the most part, the former are doing investigatory work. For the most part, the latter are not.
- Macha 6y agoI'll give you that paid outlets do more investigation, but they also do their fair share of filler stories based on AP releases, takes on press releases, or social media trends too
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoYou aren't wrong.
- pseudo0 6y agoWasn't it the NYT, the model for online subscription funded journalism, that released that incorrect story accusing Marc Andreessen of saying the word "retard" on Clubhouse? That seems about as bottom of the barrel as it gets.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cbradford 6y ago100% correct. Journalists are just looking for the adulation and affirmation of their fellow progressives, and do so by attacking the weak and defending the powerful.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]