6 ms·
Is there any practical use for color ePaper yet though? From my understanding, the technology is still limited to extremely low-saturation colors with extremel
by crazygringo 6y ago
Is there any practical use for color ePaper yet though?
From my understanding, the technology is still limited to extremely low-saturation colors with extremely low contrast as well, see [1] for example photos and how the tech works.
It's certainly not ready for advertising -- instead of a vibrant color image, it looks like something printed on newspaper and left to fade in the sun for 5 years.
And color e-readers have significantly worse contrast than black & white ones, which already aren't great.
So if you truly need usable color, it seems like you're still always going to choose a traditional LCD/OLED display. Based on the fundamental limitations of the color filters used with eInk, I don't really see a future for it. At least not unless a new technology emerges that doesn't rely on using color filters on top of traditional black-and-white eInk?
[1] https://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/color-e-paper-and-e-ink-kaleido-have-severe-limitations https://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/color-e-pape...
- Jack_Hacker 6y agoEbooks with illustrations/graphs? Text books and graphic novels come to mind.
- kgwxd 6y agoAt 31.2" though?
- rodgerd 6y agoFor some specialized uses, sure: think about researchers wanting to look at illuminated manuscripts, especially wanting to see marginalia and the like. A large, low-eyestrain way of seeing high-quality scans would be very handy.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI have Moss Roberts' translation of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms scanned to PDF. ( https://www.amazon.com/dp/0520224787/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/0520224787/ ) The product page doesn't advertise it, but the books are huge. I can't actually read my PDFs because my kindle display is much smaller than that. And yet the market for a reader with a bigger screen seems to be negligible. :(
- ComputerGuru 6y agoThere’s a lot of potential but pretty much all use cases are limited each in their own way by the current specification shortcomings. Eg for the case you mention, the display ppi is simply nowhere near good enough for minute study of details.
- dragonwriter 6y agoThat's, what, about 4-up letter pages? Yeah, I can see that being useful. Can't get to the page; I assume the price is ridiculous though.
- pmontra 6y ago$2,300.00
- crazygringo 6y agoBut that's my point -- the contrast for regular black and white text is so much worse with color eInk than it is for regular black-and-white eInk. It seems like a terrible tradeoff to make, for colors that are still terrible. Reading a graphic novel on a color e-ink reader will be so washed out... if you really want the color, it seems like you still have to just read it on an iPad etc.
- johnisgood 6y agoMost of my medical books would be better with a color E-ink. In fact, I do not even have medical books on my current E-book reader.
- ademarre 6y agoSignage. Advertisements, restaurant menu displays, etc. New artistic styles often come from the limitations of their mediums. I expect the limitations of color e-ink to be no different.
- crazygringo 6y agoI don't really see that in this case though. The whole point I'm making is that no advertiser or restaurant is going to use color eInk because the contrast and saturation are so terrible. This isn't like working around the limitations of a medium to develop pixel art, or black-and-white drawings, etc. Color e-ink is just a worse medium in every way. It's worse contrast at black-and-white (B&W e-ink is far better), and it's terrible contrast and saturation at color. I don't see it working for signs, ads, or menus at all. Color e-ink feels like a cool prototype, a proof-of-concept, but that basically demonstrates its limitations don't make it commercially viable for any general purpose.
- ip26 6y agoLCD billboards absolutely destroy my night vision. An illuminated color eink display probably would not.
- elaus 6y agoWouldn't it be technically possible to reduce the backlight for LCD displays at night? Seeing that it itsn't happening I have little hope that e-ink displays wouldn't be illuminated to the maximum as well ("out ads should be as bright and vibrant as possible!")
- neltnerb 6y agoYou can turn off the backlight for an LCD and rely on it being reflective, but the contrast is very poor since at least half the light is blocked. In this application I see the use of e-ink as being: - Maybe more readable if you're really fussy. - Lowers overall power use. The prior is super weak, LCDs do fine as long as they're not in direct sun. The second is a good reason, but not a very compelling one in terms of economics yet. The place these make sense is battery powered devices. If it's plugged in it is a gimmick or someone really dedicated to energy efficiency.
- com2kid 6y ago> Is there any practical use for color ePaper yet though? Years ago, the cafeterias at Microsoft switched from using regular signage for their menus to giant plasma TVs that showed a static image of the menu that had been there. The menu at some of the stations (but not all) did change daily, so there was some, slim, benefit, perhaps. After awhile, they moved over to having a slide show on the screens that alternated between glamour shots of the food, and the menu. Now you could only see the actual menu for a fraction of the time, and despite being a speed reader, I'd often have to wait for the menu to come back around multiple times before I could read it all and decide what I wanted to eat that day. But it sure did look modern! Further irony, IIRC that was around the same time I volunteered to be part of a campus wide partnership with the local power company and I stood at a desk in the cafeteria handing out free CFLs bulbs. The tl;dr is that companies will invest in expensive, less useful, signage, if it is perceived as being cooler. Heck it isn't like menus carved/painted on wood have particularly good contrast ratios, but they still pop up now and then.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> they moved over to having a slide show on the screens that alternated between glamour shots of the food, and the menu. Now you could only see the actual menu for a fraction of the time, and despite being a speed reader, I'd often have to wait for the menu to come back around multiple times before I could read it all and decide what I wanted to eat that day. I've seen this problem elsewhere. I don't get why you wouldn't display the menu on some of the screens and the photos on other screens.
- com2kid 6y agoThey eventually got it sorted out, but for awhile it was.... less than stellar.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe local McD's drive thru has a giant LED screen where you can see your order and total cost. Very nice for confirming they understood what you ordered after: Me: 3 Big Macs and 2 large Fries McD: What? Me: 3 Big Macs and 2 large Fries McD: 4 Quarterpounders? Me: T-h-r-e-e B-i-g M-a-c-s McD: 3 Quarterpounders? Me: Yes, and fries
- Kluny 6y agoMy favorite use-case is a laptop that I can use to write/study/code in bright sunlight.
- neltnerb 6y agoOr a phone. Do either of these exist yet as single display devices? I've only seen half measures with a regular LCD plus an e-ink add on that was very much a gimmick. I would be so thrilled for an e-ink phone to get rid of my current one with. I don't play movies, the refresh rate doesn't need to be great, it does need to be color, and if the battery lasts a week again... well worth it.
- canuckintime 6y agoHisense has been offering eink phones for the past two years. The latest iteration is the A7 CC 5G with a 6.7" 300 ppi color e-ink display
- neltnerb 6y agoOh, that's exciting! I was last looking hard in 2018 but I'm still surprised I didn't notice. Alas, I've got the whole "phone needs to be small enough to use one handed" due to disability stuff so https://www.gsmchoice.com/en/catalogue/hisense/a5c/ https://www.gsmchoice.com/en/catalogue/hisense/a5c/ is their smaller one and it's a bit big but close... Might be a wait until there's enough market for a niche of both not huge and also e-ink. There was a bar e-ink phone though! I'm surprised they can't just put a more complex OS on it given the resolution... https://www.gsmchoice.com/en/catalogue/mudita/pure/ https://www.gsmchoice.com/en/catalogue/mudita/pure/
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Is there any practical use for color ePaper yet though? > It's certainly not ready for advertising -- instead of a vibrant color image, it looks like something printed on newspaper and left to fade in the sun for 5 years. This is still a big improvement over black and white if you're displaying, say, a math textbook.
- f430 6y agoMe personally: manga, retro magazines, papers with colored charts etc. I am still looking for the day when we can read magazines, manga from the past in full vibrant color e-ink platform. edit: speaking of which I am looking to purchase high quality retro gaming magazines (PC, Playstation 1 in particular). anybody wants to get in touch please reply.
- dghlsakjg 6y agoThere's a grocery chain (Superstore, Canada) which has been using the small two color displays (black white red) for pricing. They use the tiny 2.7" e-paper screens and a TI cc2540 microcontroller to periodically update the pricing via some 2.4ghz signal (ok fine, I was curious so I stole one to take apart). Seems like a VERY expensive way to keep prices up to date. The BOM cost on one of those little guys has to be north of $10, and I would imagine that the vendor that sold them the system doesn't sell them at cost. Multiply that times thousands of products.... So yeah, people are using them, but it doesn't seem like a great system.
- miohtama 6y agoWhat is the cost on updating paper label prices? There must be a payback vs. manual labour for these systems.
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoTypical supermarket with 60,000 SKUS; $20 total cost per device = $1.2m to outfit a store. /$15 employee gross costs per hour = 38 years of labour for one store.... Either the # SKUs would have to be lower, or the BOM smaller to justify this. On the flipside consider the material cost of paper pricing tags, reduced risk of pricing error, ability to change pricing more rapidly, increased customer marketing/attraction. I'd also imagine that removing this function from individual stores and centralising it would save a considerable amount of store management time.
- cycomanic 6y agoCall me paranoid/cynical but maybe they are planning on a future system were they use the profile they have on you to calculate your preferences and buying power and update the signs on the fly when you're coming up to them. Or maybe they are already doing that ... I said to call me paranoid.
- Green_man 6y agoSome online services are already engaging in price discrimination, though physical retail has greater limitations in communicating prices to individual customers. I think that removing price tags entirely would be necessary for full price discrimination in brick and mortar retail (or some similarly revolutionary step, like AR vision placing price tags on items). That's not to say it's infeasible, but other changes may be necessary first. For example, in an Amazon Go location, you don't need to check out the items at the end. Customers would still definitely want to know prices of items, but I could imagine them caring less about seeing price tags if they aren't checking out immediately after. I think another system that could help would be a partial or full subscription model, where the subscription price could be an opportunity for price discrimination.
- neltnerb 6y agoI, as an equipment designer, would select an e-ink color display for my main feedback if: - it was battery powered and needed a display with infrequent updates but super low power - the display was otherwise a large part of the power (i.e. otherwise it was a LCD display) - the color was useful in indicating an error or clarifying the menu items If it did those things it would be worth upwards of $10 a unit to me if the resolution was over 720p for sure, and likely even for lower resolutions if it worked reliably with a slow microcontroller.
- jacques_chester 6y ago> Is there any practical use for color ePaper yet though? CI and monitoring dashboards. These tend to have large relatively static areas for long periods. Every regular LCD I've seen gets horrific burn-in after a month or three and then burns a lot of wasted electricity for bonus points.
- tarikozket 6y agodid you look at the link OP shared?