3 ms·
Why is this always trotted out as a counterargument when other countries manage to successfully write legislature around hate speech (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.
by vlovich123 6y ago
Why is this always trotted out as a counterargument when other countries manage to successfully write legislature around hate speech (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_in_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_in_Canada). The only 2 choices aren't all speech is unregulated and tyrrany. Hell, even in the US you can't yell fire in a crowded theater & the First Amendment doesn't say "except in cases the speech might cause mass panic or loss of life".
- cobraetor 6y agoAre they really successful though? In Canada for example the laws are quite controversial, regardless of political affiliation: > The controversy around the issue lies in the reasoning behind Canada’s top court decision that proclaimed Bill Whatcott, a Christian evangelist, guilty of hate speech because of the language he used to refer to homosexuality. > But in order to protect homosexuals from being perceived negatively, the Supreme Court went too far in infringing on freedom of speech, and of religion, critics said. > This criticism came from both left and right, caused by the way the judge in charge of the case explained the ruling. > “Truthful statements can be presented in a manner that would meet the definition of hate speech, and not all truthful statements must be free from restriction,” the judge wrote at the time. https://reclaimthenet.org/canada-to-use-controversial-supreme-court-hate-speech-decision/ https://reclaimthenet.org/canada-to-use-controversial-suprem... Likewise in other countries, such as Scotland: > ... famed comedian Rowan Atkinson and 20 others, including actors, philosophers, and writers, working with Humanist Society Scotland, see it as posing danger to freedom of expression, because the new legislation aims to introduce the offense of “stirring up hatred” without taking into account if hatred was the intent, bringing with it the danger of criminalizing and jailing people simply for their controversial views, the article said of the artists’ concerns. https://reclaimthenet.org/scotland-hate-speech-bill-pushback/ https://reclaimthenet.org/scotland-hate-speech-bill-pushback...
- cheeseomlit 6y agoYes, they successfully wrote hate speech laws. Just because a law is successfully written doesn't mean it's a just law. Policing peoples speech because someone somewhere deems it offensive sounds like tyranny to me. There's a big difference between yelling fire in a crowded theater and expressing a political belief that others might find distasteful.
- vlovich123 6y agoMy sincere political belief is that the First Amendment doesn't have any exceptions listed anywhere in the constitution & thus should be interpreted as an absolute. Thus either we either acknowledge that we can make regulations on top of the constitution when there's a good-faith attempt at impartiality OR the regulations are unacceptable. Since there are rulings around which regulations are & aren't allowed (e.g. Citizens United overrode an attempt at impartial regulation around the mechanics of political speech, Schenck banned falsely shouting fire in a theater, etc). In terms of the difference, please let me know what that difference is. I believe that US democracy is on fire. Why am I prohibited from raising awareness of this political issue in the public venue of my choice?