7 ms·
Drug for treating obesity cuts body weight by 20%
- meowster 6y agoPrevious discussion 5 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26113655 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26113655 (83 points, 124 comments)
- pizza234 6y agoTo consider: > [...] adhere to the reduced-calorie diet and increased > physical activity, providing guidance, behavioural > strategies and motivation. Additionally, participants > received incentives such as kettle bells or food scales to > mark progress and milestones.
- rebuilder 6y agoThe placebo group got this same regimen as well, but showed markedly less weight loss.
- Karunamon 6y agoBut don't forget: > In those taking semaglutide, the average weight loss was 15.3kg (nearly three stone), with a reduction in BMI of -5.54. The placebo group observed an average weight loss of 2.6kg (0.4 stone) with a reduction in BMI of -0.92. With n=1961, this is well beyond significant. Also, this is a hunger control drug, and anyone who's been on a diet can tell you that's probably the hardest part.
- znpy 6y ago> nearly three stone what does that mean?
- ufo 6y agoFor more context, Derek Lowe recently wrote a very interesting blog post about this drug: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/02/15/glp-1-and-obesity https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/02/15/gl... This is not a miracle drug. It needs to be injected, comes with a risk of serious side effects and we don't have long term safety data. However, diabetes and obesity are also serious so anything that promises to help on that front is welcome news.
- CivBase 6y agoWould just loosing weight actually help with diabetes? I thought it had more to do with nutrition than sheer body mass, which explains why so many non-obese people get it while many morbidly obese people never do. I can definitely see how reduced mass would help reduce strain on the heart, though.
- readthenotes1 6y agoSome people can rid themselves of type 2 diabetes by losing weight, and obesity is a known risk factor for getting it in the first place.
- CivBase 6y agoYeah, but isn't that because obesity correlates with poor nutrition and weight loss correlates with improved nutrition?
- unparagoned 6y agoNo, the actual amount of fat is a factor
- slimbods 6y agoAs Derek says at the end, there is an oral version of the drug.
- 6y ago
- rabuse 6y agoI find it unbelievable that people find it difficult to watch one's weight, and adjust accordingly. I was always very slender in my life, and wore the same size clothes for years. I began working out a few years back, and in just a few months, I started growing out of my old clothes. How can the majority of people in the U.S. not notice their weight gain, and not care at all?
- tgflynn 6y agoPeople are different. I was overweight by the time I became aware of my existence.
- rabuse 6y agoI understand people are different, but I don't understand how it's the majority.
- hyko 6y agoBiological Evolution? No props from natural selection if you’re absolutely ripped and then die from a virus the week after.
- rabuse 6y agoThen why are women so attracted to muscular men?
- rini17 6y agoDid you ask them? Many women find hypertrophied muscles off-putting.
- hyko 6y agoEveryone was probably comparatively lean looking in the circumstances in which humanity evolved; we’re talking about small differences in fat storage and metabolism that are magnified by the environment that we’ve created. Edited to add: obviously that’s before we consider the interplay between natural selection and sexual selection.
- buryat 6y agoI weigh 313kg and now I'm afraid of catching covid as I'm in the risk group, I wish I could be in trials for this drug that would change my life.
- mixedCase 6y agoAt the risk of sounding like a proselytizing bastard, but doing it out of genuine concern and sharing what little knowledge of nutrition has personally worked for me: Have you tried a low carb diet like keto?. It's the only thing that's been able to help me with fast, consistent results and the modest willpower I can dedicate to the problem. I'm sorry in case you weren't looking for advice.
- friendly_chap 6y agoAre you serious? Is that possible? No offense.
- sevenf0ur 6y agoAt that weight, isn't catching COVID pretty much a death sentence? I would be terrified too.
- ipsi 6y agoThe record for heaviest person in the world was 442KG (974lb), so yes, definitely possible.
- friendly_chap 6y agoYes, I should have googled that. To GP: sorry I meant no offense! Wishing you all the best and take care.
- Darkphibre 6y agoYes, obesity is a risk factor when catching COVID. Or, if you meant to question the truthfulness of their claims (without offense, is that possible?)... A quick internet search shows that the heaviest person recorded was 50% heavier. So, yes, the weight described is certainly possible.
- miles 6y ago> The drug, semaglutide, works by hijacking the body’s own appetite regulating system in the brain leading to reduced hunger and calorie intake. So the same weight loss can be accomplished by simply eating less. Intermittent fasting is great for that[0]: > I prefer the daily method: Fast for at least 16 hours per day. The aforementioned New England Journal of Medicine study was based on an 18:6 structure: 18-hour fast, six-hour window. > "16:8 is a great place to start," Stephens says, "but it may not be a weight-loss window for many people. That's because fat-burning ramps up between hours 18 and 24 of the fast. 19:5 was a great weight-loss sweet spot for me, and I lost at about a pound per week when doing it. With 19:5, you fast for 19 hours a day and have an eating window of five hours. Your sweet spot may be different from mine, of course. Maybe it will be 18:6 or 20:4." Experimentation is key, she adds. [0] https://www.cnet.com/health/intermittent-fasting-lose-weight-get-healthier-and-save-money/ https://www.cnet.com/health/intermittent-fasting-lose-weight...
- mgarfias 6y agoI'm on it for the past two years or so. Haven't lost the 20% weight yet. Still waiting. Its kept the blood glucose #s in better check, but it was a nudge vs a big shove. Then again, i'm on 1mg/week, rather than the 2.4mg that the study used. What _HAS_ helped me is keeping track of what i'm eating, and making sure i account for the occasional snack, and various things I'd drop on my food (sour cream on tacos for instance).