7 ms·
Are there any good papers on the BTC network robustness in the event of war. It is well known that major military powers have the ability to cut essentially ev
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
Are there any good papers on the BTC network robustness in the event of war.
It is well known that major military powers have the ability to cut essentially every ocean-floor optical fiber bundle handling the backbone of the internet at a moment’s notice.
If this happens, how would the bitcoin network respond without active connections to other mining nodes?
E.g. would the Chinese miners automatically (algorithmically) decide that they are the only existing miners, and so on and so forth?
Would an act like this essentially fork bitcoin into country segments because each communicating sub-group would think they have the ground truth until the global internet is physically reconnected?
Would love to see a simulation of this.
- nooneiswatching 6y agoVery interesting thought. I believe that chains would initially split, effectively being forks of each other. However, the consensus algorithm of Bitcoin dictates that the chain with the most work is the valid one, meaning that in the event of a "reconnection", one of the chains would be abandoned (and everyone would agree which one to keep, namely the one with the most work). In the case of a total disconnect between countries, there is no other way than splitting the network. If partial connectivity exists (using satellites for example), transactions could still be broadcasted from one country to another. However, the same coins could be double-spent in your own isolated network as well... until a reorg happens upon reconnect.
- Hydraulix989 6y agoPhilosophical question: At what point do divergent chains become irreconcilably and separately valid? Is this a property we would ever want in a should-be decentralized currency? One way this can happen today is with intentional forks.
- Jimmc414 6y agoThat is actually a good and very practical question.
- Hydraulix989 6y agoI think it reduces to the chains will always have to be reconciled because you would otherwise open yourself up to N% attacks where N is whatever threshold you decided was "safe.'
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SahAssar 6y agoI'm guessing that when they all reconnect again the longest chain would win and basically all the other forks would roll back, so essentially only the transactions of the continent with the most hash power would stay. IIRC bitcoin does not have any conflict resolution besides "most work wins".
- Imnimo 6y agoBut won't each continent adjust its difficulty to account for its local hashrate? And would a high difficulty fork accept that a low difficulty longer fork is valid? Or would it reject it for having invalid blocks?
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe algorithm is tuned so that a block is mined about every 10min no matter what the hashing power available is. In the case of a serious and persistent network partition, both “sides” would continue to mine blocks at roughly the same rate as before, minus the first blocks that would take a while as the algorithm tried to catch up to the drastically reduced local hashing power. The real issue is what happens once the partition is healed, and it’s not a technical problem. The technical solution is straightforward: longest chain wins. The real issue is a social one: how do you deal with finding out that the last N months worth of transactions are just gone?
- Imnimo 6y agoIf I'm stranded in Antarctica, and decide to compute hashes with my pocket calculator to pass the time, and drop the difficulty to zero (because I can do one hash every 10 min, so they all have to be winners), does the bitcoin protocol say that my chain of empty blocks is a valid contender for longest chain? Or does "longest chain" also take into account difficulty? (Setting aside the obvious fact that in reality everyone would obviously just ignore me)
- ashtonkem 6y agoThis isn’t quite how the algorithm works. To make a valid block, you have to start with another valid block. The difficulty is set (edit: I was wrong, and I fixed this) every 2016 blocks based on how long they took to mine. This works out to about 2 weeks at the expected rate of mining. The average time of those 2016 blocks is then used to calculate the difficulty of the next 2016 blocks, and the difficulty is marked down in the chain itself. So in your hypothetical you’d have to solve around two weeks worth of blocks at the current difficulty level, which isn’t possible in a human lifespan. After that the difficulty for your chain would rapidly fall, but your sub-chain would already be very far behind and would never catch up.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoI hope mesh networks and satellite internet connections are robust enough to counter this.
- csomar 6y agoThis was actually one of the reasons Bitcoin Core devs were opposed to raising the block limit. Bitcoin requires very little bandwidth (around 1.5mb/10minutes). You can actually get the Bitcoin blockchain from Satellite for free: https://blockstream.com/satellite/ https://blockstream.com/satellite/ However, as I understand it, it only allows receiving and not transmitting data.
- gruez 6y ago>However, as I understand it, it only allows receiving and not transmitting data. what about something like shortwave radio? You probably can't have everyone transmitting at the same time, but a few stations around to world can broadcast/relay transactions across pockets of connectivity.
- scsilver 6y agoI think starlink is up and would provide the secondary line.
- HDMI_Cable 6y ago> It is well known that major military powers have the ability to cut essentially every ocean-floor optical fiber bundle handling the backbone of the internet at a moment’s notice. I'm not doubting your statement, but I would love to hear where you got that point from, since it seems really interesting.